‘PS I Love You’ was written primarily by Paul McCartney around the time of The Beatles’ 1962 trip to Hamburg. It was first released as the b-side to their debut single ‘Love Me Do’, and later appeared on the Please Please Me album.
It’s just an idea for a song really, a theme song based on a letter, like the ‘Paperback Writer’ idea. It was pretty much mine. I don’t think John had much of a hand in it. There are certain themes that are easier than others to hang a song on, and a letter is one of them. ‘Dear John’ is the other version of it. The letter is a popular theme and it’s just my attempt at one of those. It’s not based in reality, nor did I write it to my girlfriend [Dot Rhone] from Hamburg, which some people think
Many Years From Now, Barry Miles
The sentimental lyrics of ‘PS I Love You’ proved especially popular with The Beatles’ female fans, and it soon became a fixture of their live shows.
That’s Paul’s song. He was trying to write a ‘Soldier Boy’ like the Shirelles. He wrote that in Germany or when we were going to and from Hamburg. I might have contributed something. I can’t remember anything in particular. It was mainly his song.
All We Are Saying, David Sheff
Initially the song was mooted as a possible a-side, a notion that Richards quickly dismissed. “I was originally a music publishing man, a plugger, so I knew that someone had already done a record with that title,” he said. He was referring to a 1934 song by Gordon Jenkins and Johnny Mercer, originally recorded by Rudy Vallée.
In the studio
The Beatles first recorded an unknown number of takes of ‘PS I Love You’ at their first Abbey Road session on 6 June 1962, with Pete Best on drums. Then, during the second ‘Love Me Do’ session on 11 September, they remade it in 10 takes.
Ringo Starr didn’t play drums on the record. Producer Ron Richards brought session player Andy White in as a replacement, as Starr hadn’t proved good enough during the band’s 4 September session. Starr, sadly, was relegated to maracas during ‘PS I Love You’.
BBC recordings
The Beatles recorded ‘PS I Love You’ three times for BBC radio sessions.
The first was for the 26 October 1962 edition of Here We Go, which was recorded the previous day. The other songs recorded for the show were the unreleased ‘Sheila’, ‘Love Me Do’, and ‘A Taste Of Honey’.
The second BBC recording was for The Talent Spot. It was taped on 27 November 1962 and broadcast on 4 December 1962. The Beatles performed three songs: ‘Love Me Do’, ‘PS I Love You’, and ‘Twist And Shout’.
The third and final BBC version of ‘PS I Love You’ was for Pop Go The Beatles. It was recorded on 17 June 1963 and broadcast on 25 June.
The Beatles recorded seven songs for the programme: ‘Anna (Go To Him)’, ‘I Saw Her Standing There’, ‘Boys’, ‘Chains’, ‘PS I Love You’, ‘Twist And Shout’, and ‘A Taste Of Honey’. This version of ‘PS I Love You’ was included on 2013’s On Air – Live At The BBC Volume 2.
I have some corrections or suggestions:
1) There is no real lead guitar in here. George is playing a Gibson Jumbo like John and it’s also just an acoustic rhythm part what he played.
2) Again, like on the song “Please Please Me”, I would distinguish the vocals: Paul is on lead, John is doing harmony (and backing), George sings backing.
3) There are no drums in it, Andy White played percussion (woodblocks).
That’s great – thanks for the information. All improvements and amendments are always welcome!
There is certainly lead guitar with tremolo throughout the song, most notably accenting Lennon’s backing vocals (“Treasure… words… together… forever…”. I’d like that to be corrected. So Harrison played acoustic guitar and lead guitar.
John played guitar on it too and in fact, both he and George played their Gibson J-160E acoustic guitars in electric mode, hence the hybrid electric/acoustic tone.
I always thought it sounded like a hi-hat and rim-shots. I’ve heard it thousands of times. Now I have to REALLY listen to it! ?
George didn’t own a Gibson Jumbo at this time. He & John thought they had ordered two Jumbo’s from Gibson like the Everly Bros. had but they received j160’s from Gibson instead which is what they are using on this recording.
The J160E IS INDEED a Gibson Jumbo (hence the letter “J” in it’s model name).
Kinda silly that George Martin (or Ron Richards?) didn’t think Ringo capable of playing such a minimal rhythm track. (WOODBLOCKS, for chrissakes – a ten-year-old could’ve done it!) Unless they just decided to get the most out of Andy White, since they’d taken the trouble of booking him (for “Love Me Do”.)
Such a cute, brief little ditty! I always liked this one. For me, it’s all about the “You you you” hook and the one-word-per-bar backing vocal.
Andy White actually played bongos, not drums.
I think it’s a necessary song. I simple little track that was a slight departure from their rhythm/lead/bass/drums basic setup of virtually all of their early work. I see why it would be a hit live with the ladies.
The recording sounds a bit muffled to me for some reason. I would like to have heard it live to see if there was a difference in quality. Not one of my favs on the album, but a good B side. Surprising pick to go with “Love Me Do” though, as it’s even slower than that number. But they picked up the pace very soon.
I don’t believe it was a case of Ringo not being good enough. I’ve heard George Martin say in interviews that he didn’t even know everything about Ringo coming in to be the drummer and had already hired and paid for Andy White to do the session. And since George had already paid for White, he was going to use him. Afterwards when George got a chance to properly hear Ringo play, he quickly got the job.
Correct. George Martin thought that Pete best was still in the band at this point, and thought Best would not be capable of delivering what was needed for the recording. Thus, Andy White was brought in.
Wrong. Sept 4 – expecting Pete Best to play drums, the Beatles showed up with Ringo which upset Mr. Martin and resulted in words between him and Brian Epstein.
Since it was decided that nothing from that session would be released, another session was scheduled for Sept 11 with RON RICHARDS producing. HE decided that since the drummer had been an issue on both the previous sessions (June 4 and Sept 4) that he would take no chances and hired Andy White. Thus, White was used when it was already known that Ringo was the Beatles’ drummer.
Very underrated song and record in my book. Beautiful melody. Still boggles the mind that a 20 year old, self-taught `kid’ could write this!
Often the best songs are written at a young age.You ponder for years, then write your most heart felt lyrics, often on your first or second LP,if given the opportunity.
Absolutely one of my favorite very early Beatles songs. Paul’s vocals are especially good.
Can anyone tell if it is John or Paul that sings the “Ohhh” at about 1:24 just before Paul chimes in with “you know I want you to remember..”? It sounds like John at first, but it also sounds like the voice Paul uses when singing the “you know..” part. It’s bugging me that I can’t tell!
The first ohh is John, then Paul´s : You know I want you to remember … and, at last, George gives us a yeah !
I have always thought it was Paul for the three parts. Still thinks it’s Paul.
Definitely Paul. Listen to Live at the BBC. It’s clearly him on that cut. Why would they perform a “harder” take on the “live” version?
Paul scatting “oh-oh-oh” at the end of the chorus line, then the end of the next chorus line,
“You-know-I-want you-to-remember”, the “remember” falls Exactly on the beginning of the next chorus line. Brilliant!
Yes, you are correct sir!
John sings the exact same style “Ohh!!” on All I’ve Got To Do. On PS I Love You, it is indeed John first, then Paul, then George’s “yeahhh”. I fun little piece of trivia!
Wow this is the first I’ve ever heard of this and it just blew my mind!!! That’s so awesome, it’s always been one of my favorites and now this just makes it so much better!!! Thank you Beatle Buddies!!!!
Correct – the three vocalists each get a solo in the final refrain.
Kedame – I always assumed it was Paul since, as you mentioned, he continues with the answering part afterward. However, you’re right — that “Oh!” does indeed sound like John. I’ve noticed on other songs how John and Paul’s voices sound eerily similar, often for just a single word. Case and point: check out “Penny Lane” @ 1:39, when Paul sings the word “summer.”
Yes !! Finally someone else hears that “summer” thing too.
Anybody else hear the mellotron chord mistake at 0:24 ?
The ” summer ” really sounds like John. Are you sure it’s Paul’s singing that ?
It is John singing, “…in summer” and Paul singing, “…meanwhile back” …no need to drive yourselves crazy…it is exactly what it sounds like!
Like in “Like dreamers do” Paul sings Elvis´s style.
I don’t buy the part about George Martin saying that he didn’t know anything about Ringo coming in on this session and that’s why Andy White was booked. This was the Sept. 11th session, not the Sept. 4th session, which Ringo was already used on. It makes no sense. It seems to me that if George Martin had originally been unhappy with Pete Best’s drumming & had decided to use a session drummer for the next upcoming session, wouldn’t it make more sense to have Andy White at the Sept. 4th session rather than the Sept. 11th one? Something about the chronology of all of this just never sat right with me…
How’s this for a scenario (I don’t know if it happened this way, but it’s the only way that makes sense to me):
June 6 – Pete on drums. George Martin doesn’t like it, tells Brian Epstein that a session drummer will be used on all future sessions.
Sept 4 – Since George Martin is supposedly unaware that Pete’s out & Ringo’s in, Andy White is booked & on Stand-by (possibly in another room or the Control Booth, with The Beatles unaware). Once George Martin is aware of the drummer change, he decides to try Ringo out as long as he’s there. Many times a session musician will be called & not used.
Sept 11 – Andy White is booked & used at this session to see if there is any improvement over the previous one. There isn’t. Take the tambourine off of this day’s version of “Love Me Do” & this day’s & the Sept 4 versions are virtually identical.
I’m trying to look at this from George Martin’s point of view at the time. If he was unhappy with the June 6 session, & was under the impression that Pete was still with the group when the Sept 4 session rolled around, why wouldn’t a session drummer already also be booked for that day? Why would George run the risk of having two sessions in a row with (what was to him at the time) unsatisfactory drumming? Not having a session man at the second session when the first one was unsatisfactory just makes no sense to me.
Let’s look at this from purely a musician’s standpoint also: These early songs are not that complicated. There’s no drastic tempo changes or anything like that. They’re definitely not “Rain”, “Tomorrow Never Knows” or “A Day In The Life”…
This is how this confusion got resolved in Lewisohn’s book “Tune In”. As you say, on June 6th George Martin wasn’t happy with Pete & decided to use session drummers from then on, next – before September 4th – George’s assistant (later to become his wife) Judy Lockhart-Smith was notified by Brian Epstein that the Beatles have a new drummer, Ringo. On this second session, things were going well, until – as Ringo says himself – he had a mad moment when he decided to beat his drums with “maracas in one hand & tambourine in the other” instead of sticks. He was SO terrified of his first recording session with the band and of George & Judy, who were “awfully uppercrust” & “posh” in Ringo’s mind. Because of that “mad moment” Andy White was brought in next week. Ringo had NEVER forgiven George Martin for that decision & ALWAYS reminded him of it, although it wasn’t necessarily his decision, but Ron Richards’ (George’s recording assistant). Some months later on November 16th 1962 Beatles & George had an “eye-opening” meeting where George decided to make an ALBUM with them. He committed that day to fully producing them. 10 days later, “Please Please Me” single was recorded with Ringo & now all was well. That’s how it happened!
It´s interesting that their first single contains TWO Paul´s songs, considering John was the lead singer on most of the songs those early years. Even on stage. Just funny.
Love Me Do was co-written according to Paul. Prior to the recording, John sang lead on stage. Paul sang lead for the recording because John had to play the harmonica.
Why Paul sounded nervous had to sing the whole song , think John was playing harmonica at the same time.
Both guitars are electrified acoustic Gibsons I guess.
Correct – John and George were playing their Gibson J-160Es on the electric setting, hence the unique hybrid electric/acoustic sound.
PS I love you in real stereo. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pq1gv3u03gw
always wondered why ps i love you was the b-side. i know about the “there was already a song
with that title, but to my ear it’s just a catchier song than love me do ever was. has george martin
ever talked about that.
Agreed Chip. PS was the stronger musically and received numerous radio requests despite being tucked away as a B side.
I don’t know,but while love me do reached about number 16 on th e charts I feel ps I ole you could have gone to no 1.I love it.
Wow no one seems to mention how John’s one word per line backing vocals only lasted until 1:36, when he sings the whole line in harmony with Paul. For me it’s John backing vocals that makes this song so appealing!
“Back in the day” while tuned in to the Casey Kasem Show, he told of a
studio situation where Ringo used a matchbox for “tapping” sound while recording P.S. I Love You. While always believing that to be true, I find no mention of it anywhere. Am I wrong? Was it a different song? The Maraca’s are not that believable and the woodblock is a Maybe? HELP!
That was “I’m Looking Through You” from Rubber Soul.
A good track , and should have been the A-side. Funny to think it was the title that relegated it to the back-side. In the years since, titles are used, re-used, and re-re-used – no one cares, really.
Since it is indicated that the song was recorded on June 6 and September 11, shouldn’t Pete Best be listed in the Personnel section?
If “Starr … was relegated to maracas,” then Andy White was too. From drums to woodblocks:)
I don’t see this as a number 1 song or an A-Side song even, a really underwhelming song
with some nice vocals by Paul but that’s it.
Well, “Love Me Do” is a fairly underwhelming song as well. ‘twix the two, “P.S. …” is the better.