One of Lennon and McCartney’s earliest songs, ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’ was written in 1959 at McCartney’s family home in Allerton, Liverpool.
I wrote that in my front parlour in Forthlin Road. I was about 16. ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’ was one of those very early ones. I seem to remember writing it just after I’d had the flu and I had that cigarette – I smoked when I was 16 – the cigarette that’s the ‘cotton wool’ one. You don’t smoke while you’re ill but after you get better you have a cigarette and it’s terrible, it tastes like cotton wool, horrible. I remember standing in the parlour, with my guitar, looking out through the lace curtains of the window, and writing that one.
The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, Mark Lewisohn
A rough home recording of the song exists on bootleg, believed to date from spring 1960. Lasting 1’49”, it was performed by McCartney, Lennon and Harrison on acoustic guitars, with Stuart Sutcliffe on bass, without the delicate arrangement of the Beatles For Sale version.
McCartney told Peter Hodgson, from whom he bought the tape in 1995, that it was recorded in the bathroom of his home during a school holiday in April 1960. Intriguingly, it featured different lyrics and music, plus a brief guitar break by Harrison, in place of the section which eventually began ‘And now the time has come, and so my love I must go’. The lyrics are hard to decipher, but appear to be:
Well don’t leave me alone, my dear
I’ll hurry, and call on me my sweet
While never a core part of The Beatles’ live repertoire, Pete Best recalled ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’ being played on a piano by McCartney between sets at Hamburg’s Kaiserkeller.
It wouldn’t have been considered good enough [to be performed by the group]. I wouldn’t have put it up. As I said before, we had this R&B image in Liverpool, a rock ‘n’ roll, R&B, hardish image with the leather. So I think that songs like ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’, ballads like that, got pushed back to later.
The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, Mark Lewisohn
The song was revived during the hurried sessions for Beatles For Sale at the end of 1964, when the group were struggling to find enough songs to fill the album. It was first released in the US on the Beatles ’65 collection.
That’s Paul again. Can’t you tell? I mean, ‘Tomorrow may rain so I’ll follow the sun.’ That’s another early McCartney. You know, written almost before The Beatles, I think. He had a lot of stuff…
All We Are Saying, David Sheff
The group also recorded ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’ for Top Gear, a BBC radio programme. It was recorded on 17 November 1964, transmitted on 26 November, but wasn’t commercially released until the ‘Baby It’s You’ single in 1995.
In the studio
On 18 October 1964 The Beatles recorded ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’ in eight takes. The final version was the only one to feature electric guitar; previous attempts all contained an acoustic guitar break.
Disc, 14 November 1964
McCartney later claimed that Starr played body percussion rather than a packing case.
On the record we got Ringo to tap his knees. We were thinking in terms of singles and the next one had to always be different. We didn’t want to fall into the Supremes trap where they all sounded rather similar, so to that end, we were always keen on having varied instrumentation. Ringo couldn’t keep changing his drum kit, but he could change his snare, tap a cardboard box or slap his knees.
Many Years From Now
In July 2008 it was announced that a newly-discovered reel-to-reel tape of The Beatles recording ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’ would be sold at auction, with an estimated price of £8,000 to £12,000. It eventually went for £9,800.
Along with ‘I’ll Follow The Sun’, the 30-minute tape featured versions of ‘Don’t Put Me Down Like This’, ‘I Feel Fine’, ‘She’s A Woman’, ‘Everybody’s Trying To Be My Baby’, ‘Honey Don’t’, ‘I’m A Loser’, ‘Too Much Monkey Business’, ‘Nitty Gritty’, ‘Something’s Gotta Hold Of Me’, and ‘I Shall Not Be Moved’.
Paul played bass on this (you can hear the bass notes), there is no acoustic lead guitar in the released version. According to Georff Emerick, John played acoustic lead in early takes but the final has George with an electric guitar.
Thanks for that. If I’d only listened a bit more carefully I would have spotted that it’s an electric lead – it’s pretty clear to hear!
It’s probably Paul also playing the acoustic?
According to Emerick (as I recall from his book), George was allowed to replace John on lead for this song after grumbling that he was, after all, the lead guitarist. Emerick also relates how George, after laying down a painfully obvious lead, wanted to have another go at it but was rebuffed by an impatient George Martin. Tells you something about George’s place in the pecking order at Beatles recording sessions, circa 1964…
does anyone know what kind of guitar Paul and George were playing
Paul did not play guitar on this song – John and George did – and besides, Paul didn’t have a left-handed electric guitar to play nor did he have his Epiphone Texan yet.
I agree with you that there is no acoustic lead guitar on this allegedly played by Paul, but you must also remember not to take Geoff Emerick’s book seriously, because of the many factual errors and dubious anecdotes that he claimed to remember, not to mention that Geoff himself stated in a 1979 interview that he could not remember much about his work with the band at EMI.
Judging from the second guitar, not the solo, in tandem with the syncopated acoustic guitar that is obviously played by John, it is very jazzy in tone and perhaps George was playing his Gibson J-160E as well, but in electric mode, before overdubbing the brief but nicely played 8-note guitar solo on his Gretsch Tennessean or Gretsch Country Gentleman.
How Ian MacDonald could insinuate that Paul played acoustic guitar on this song alongside John is beyond preposterous – it is not realistic – and remember: Paul could not have possibly played George’s right-handed acoustic guitar and he didn’t even get his Epiphone Texan until December 1964, by which time “Beatles for Sale” was complete and released in the UK.
Andy Babiuk in his excellent book “Beatles Gear. The Ultimate Edition” claims that: “Paul acquired his Epiphone Texan probably in the summer of 1964” (pp. 256, 257).
Thank you for your reply, Speed skater.
Paul didn’t use his Epiphone Texan in the studio until 1965 and yes, I do acknowledge that there is some uncertainty as to when he actually obtained the guitar – sources vary and state either 1964 or 1965.
ive heard the demo…. ive heard the live BBC version…. anyone ever hear takes 1-7???
The liner notes to Beatles For Sale proclaim this to be a double-tracked vocal from Paul which it clearly isn’t; John sings the lead harmony during the verse and bridge.
It sounds like George on the verse.
Correct. It’s John
Is it just me, or is that George’s unmistakable harmony on the verse? Clearly, it’s John’s harmony on the bridge.
Lennon sings the low HARMONY, but McCartney is double tracked on the first verse line, e.g. “one day you’ll look to see I’ve gone” and then reverts to single on the title line (“but tomorrow may rain…”). The difference is clear. The harmonies on the middle 8 are a different part.
A good early attempt from Paul. Sounds very pre-Beatles – Much like “Do you want to know a secret?”. This one could have been given to the likes of Chad and Jeremy as was John’s “From a window”. Sweet and simple, but not memorable.
Billy Shears,
“From A Window” was mainly written by Paul McCartney for Billy J. Kramer, released on July 17, 1964.
The Liner notes on this song are correct. This is Paul’s song who is double tracked. John just provides a lower harmony in the bridge, that’s it.
Paul is not double-tracked, John sings with him in unison on the parts the album sleeve had mistaken as a McCartney double-vocal. You can obviously hear the nasal Lennon resonance…
Nope. Paul is clearly double-tracked in the verses. (listening to it right now).
I wrote the above after hearing this song for the first time in a while (years). Now, after hearing it several times in the past year, I can convince myself that it’s Paul double-tracked or Paul & John singing together.
I don’t REALLY hear John, but in spots it doesn’t sound quite like Paul, either. And I question whether they would bother with double-tracking (a oft-times
laborious process) on an obvious album filler track.
Who knows…
First time I get involved in one of these (who is singing?)
I say it’s John and Paul. At the very start I actually hear more John than Paul.
Paul is double tracked for the first half of each line and single for “but tomorrow may rain so I’ll follow the sun”
John sings low harmony on the bridges
John plays acoustic main guitar on left channel
George plays electric guitar on right channel with a dubbed in electric solo over the original electric guitar also on left channel
I cant believe the scarce amount of comments on this simplistic yet beautiful early ballad by Paul. I prefere it to yesterday and I believe that it’s certainly better than most tracks on BFS.
it is one of my 3 tied for first fav Beatles songs. George Martin went on camera and said he loved it to, only bad thing was it wasn’t very long. if you are really interested, my other co-fav Beatles songs are Oh Darling and I Will.
I Will has been described as the follow up to this
One day you’ll look to see ive gone Clearly sounds like George singing that and the other verses before Paul comes in with For tomorrow may rain,,,,,,,,,,,Anyone else here agree with me. Correct me if i am wrong.
I alway used to think it was George! People would say “No, this is Paul” but i’d just think “I grew up thinking these men were gods.. surely, i know their voices..?” Eventually i gave up my thoughts, but i still think Paul sounds alot like George in this one.
George did not sing on this song
The start is clearly George. Paul has a warmer voice that follows George on the high notes.
Hello everyone. I’m the one who thinks he hears some kind of organ or piano Rhodes kind in this song? I have not read anything about it. Can anyone say if you think so?
I CAN say I think not.
Its John and Paul singing like on the bbc live version
I must confess my earlier statement (George) was wrong.
This is John singing at the start.
Why would John and Paul let George start singing on a song that he had nothing to do with the writing of.
In the hierarchy of those days George was there to support what the two Gods had decided. And they would not give George the lead.
George frequently sang backing vocals and he was allowed to sing lead vocals as well.
Lovely song, obviously more of a Paul McCartney number. It was an early number he and John worked on. Fits nicely in to “Beatles For Sale”.
I love that song! Paul’s voice is lovely here, the lyrics could mean a lot and honestly- that’s my personal gem on ” Beatles for Sale” ( I love the whole album though;-))
It sounds to me the lyrics may be “Don’t leave me alone I’ll be ‘ere, (til) I’ve heard an apology my sweet”
I remember hearing this one as a little kid and thinking it was a cowboy song: “One day you’ll look and see a gun.”
This song has an interesting, non-standard chord progression, and the third and fourth notes of the melody – Eb & A over an F7 chord – are quite unusual and give it a kind of haunting, wistful feeling. I’ve always loved that aspect of it. It’s impressive that McCartney wrote it while so young. What an intuitive genius.
I’ll Follow The Sun/I Don’t Want To Spoil The Party was released as a single in Norway. It didn’t sell so well, so the single itself with cover is very rare. I have seen two singles for sale on Discogs, but both of them are without cover.
“I’ll Follow the Sun” has always been one of my favourite Paul McCartney (Beatles’ songs). I confess to being a McCartney fan because I like the optimism in his songs. (Of course this is just one of many reasons.) Don’t get me wrong, as I’m a huge fan of John, George, and Ringo too!
Whenever I’ve found myself at an impasse in life, this song has popped in my head, and it’s almost given me permission to seek an alternate, more favourable outcome. Sometimes you just can’t win with certain people no matter how hard you might try. For me, when that happens, after I’ve given something my best effort, I leave “the rain” behind, and”I follow the sun”. And voila, I feel better because I’ve left the rut behind. (Onward to the next one!)
Thanks Paul (and all of The Beatles). Your music has always been there for me! It has always touched me on a very personal level. I can’t say this about a lot of other recording artists. Another reason why The Beatles will always be so great – their universal themes and incredible creativity appeal to the hearts and minds of all generations.
Pleasant. Nice to listen to, but not approaching the greatest thing Paul ever wrote. It is what it is – a nice album track.
I first heard this song in the late ’60s, while watching The Beatles cartoon! Loved it then and still do. Thank you, Sir Paul!!
First time Beatles performed I wanna hold your hand in US Lennon’s without voice ! Yet you hear him as Paul produces his sound in the background ….Look at him work on it ! Only letting go by mistake if you ask me , sticking in the second I Wanna Hold to his own harmony , John’s voice faded completely ! Never be surprised if the man with the thousand voices could sound -a little- like John’s too ……!
This song speaks straight to my heart. It is absolutely lovely. Thank you Paul, the loss of my first love has been devastating, but this makes me feel better. “Although I lose a friend in the end you will know” and “Someday you’ll know I was the one” provide so much comfort, as well as a deep pain of knowing you must go on without them. I pray it gets better, time heals all.
I first heard this song on Christmas Day, 1964. I was 7. One of my older siblings received the album as a Christmas present, and commandeered the new Show & Tell phonograph player (Mom and Dad wouldn’t let the Beatles or any other rock and roll on the stereo for fear of ruining it for Frank Sinatra). I remember looking up from whatever I was playing with at that moment, and thinking this was one of the best songs ever…I loved the Beatles already, but this iced it. Then, a few years later, George wrote Here Comes the Sun. Wow.