Originally intended for the A Hard Day’s Night soundtrack, ‘I’ll Cry Instead’ was replaced with ‘Can’t By Me Love’ at the request of director Richard Lester. It was restored for an opening collage sequence during the film’s 1986 VHS reissue.
I wrote that for A Hard Day’s Night, but Dick Lester didn’t even want it. He resurrected ‘Can’t Buy Me Love’ for that sequence instead. I like the middle eight to that song, though – that’s about all I can say about it.
Written by John Lennon, the lyrics for ‘I’ll Cry Instead’ hint at the misogyny which Lennon would more explicitly reveal in ‘Run For Your Life’. His confessions of insecurity, meanwhile, would later be explored in the likes of ‘Help!’ and ‘You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away’.
Lennon’s wife Cynthia later described such songs as reflecting “the frustration he felt at that time. He was the idol of millions, but the freedom and fun of the early days had gone.”
The music, meanwhile, was influenced by country and western, a genre The Beatles, and in particular Ringo Starr, were fans of.
In the studio
‘I’ll Cry Instead’ was recorded on 1 June 1964. During the same afternoon session The Beatles also recorded ‘Matchbox’ and ‘Slow Down’.
The Beatles taped ‘I’ll Cry Instead’ in two parts, Section A and Section B, which were mixed and edited together on 4 June. The first part took six takes to record; the second just two.
Capitol Records released the album Something New in July 1964 in mono and stereo. The mono version contained a longer version of ‘I’ll Cry Instead’ which had a third verse – with identical lyrics to the first – extending the time from 1:48 to 2:09.
The precise reason is unclear. Capitol were using mixes received from EMI in London. When George Martin mixed and edited the song on 4 June, it seems likely that he set aside a version with the third verse to be sent to the US, possibly before he had decided to make the cut. By the time the song was mixed in stereo, on 22 June 1964, the decision to shorten the song had already been made.
Again MacDonald is wrong. John played the tambourine during his vocal overdub.
Burn Walter Everett’s book if it is your source, because he’s wrong about EVERY song. Ringo played the tambourine, as usual.
To be honest, that sounds like maracas and not tambourine. Short, quick and choppy and less aggressive tone than tambourine.
No it has the splash of a tambourine. There’s clearly the jangle.
That’s what I’m thinking too and John would never have mistrusted Ringo with percussion overdubs, as he had very high regard for him as a drummer as well as a true friend and bandmate.
I know that it’s very likely to be Ringo on tambourine and yes I do acknowledge that Walter Everett made mistakes in his book, but that’s not to say that he never got any line-ups right: he correctly stated that Paul, John and George all played acoustic guitars on “Michelle” (session photographs confirm this), John played piano on “Something” and John used his 12-string acoustic guitar on “Honey Don’t” and “I’m a Loser”.
Do you think that the longer version of I’ll Cry Instead was made on June 4 1964?
They were edited together on that day, yes. The longer version (normally heard on the US Capitol releases) is still a combination of parts A and B, but with an extra verse left in that wasn’t included in the UK version.
I think an extra verse on I’ll Cry Instead is from one of the takes the Beatles recorded. Right, Joe?
No, the extra verse is not from a Beatles take. It was recorded by the Sesame Street band featuring Elmo on vocals who were visiting from the future
Sounds like a precursor of “Run for Your Life” to me. 🙂 I just love how John sings minor thirds (although not just quite! more something like blue notes) over the major chords in the verses.
I wish the early longer version of I’ll Cry Instead which is 2:04 was released in worldwide, especially the United Kingdom.
Is this the first `country-rock’ song ever? Your thoughts please.
Great song. I love George’s Carl Perkins like solo.John’s voice is good. one of my favorites.
Ive heard at least 3 versions of I’ll Cry Instead:
-The short version
-The long version with no noticable edits. The repeat of the first verse is slightly different than the first time around, therefore not a splice.
-A long version, but its strikingly obvious they just copied the first verse and tacked it on as a third verse. The splice at 1:15 is obvious.
Anyone else notice this?
I think the original long version was spliced for the film. In fact, only two mixes exist, the original mono long version released in the U.S. and the stereo short version.
Lennon sounds great..Harrison’s guitar licks are superb.this album was the best album they made..not sgt pepper
This is a gem. Love john’s vocals on this.
I think John should have given this song for Ringo to sing…
He didn’t sing any song on AHDN and this suits well his style.
There would be more variety as well given John sings the majority of songs on the album
I think the reason why Ringo didn’t get a vocal showcase on AHDN was because at the very last sessions, he was in the hospital with tonsillitis and pharyngitis and obviously, there was no time to write and record a song for him to sing.
This is my guess on how the two different duration mono versions came to be:
The authentic mono “long” definitely has a splice, but the repeat of the first verse comes from the “B section” recording. This explains why the repeated verse has a unique performance and why the sound of the mix/balance changes at that verse.
Lewisohn reports only a single mono remix being created — that on June 4th. How, then, could the US release include the repeated verse, but the UK omits it?
Lewisohn also reports two identical sets of tape copies of the mono remixes were made on June 9th, which were intended for the US (one copy to Capitol and the other to United Artists).
My theory is…
a) The mono remix was originally made with the repeated first verse, and that was the remix that was used for the tape copies sent to the US.
b) At some point *after* the tape copies had been shipped to the US, the decision was made to delete the repeated verse. This edit was performed on the original mono remix, but could not be done to the tape copies.
c) The decision to remove the verse was taken before any stereo remixes were created. Thus by the time a stereo remix (or tape copy) went to the US, it was identical to the UK stereo remix (created on June 22).
What’da’yall think?
Nice song. Great feel. ‘Some Other Guy’ riff over and over though.
Ill Cry Instead by John is a great song, not related to Some Other Guy
Outstanding John Lennon number. Unlike one of the other contributors, I am pleased Lennon sings this himself. The ” chip on my shoulder” etc line points towards themes that would reoccur in John Lennon’s songs on “Beatles For Sale”, “Help!” and “Rubber Soul”. As some one else said particularly “Run For Your Life” off the latter album. Most famously you can point to “Jealous Guy” off the”Imagine” album,( I am talking now about his solo records now), “Scared” a brilliant number off “Walls and Bridges” and one of the best off “Double Fantasy”, “I’m Losing You”. The insecurity theme would come up in particular in his dealings with women. His honesty in writing about this side of himself resulted in some of John Lennon’s best songs. “I’ll Cry Instead” may not have been used in the”A Hard Days Night” film but it helps in making up a batch of great songs for side two of the album.
Hello Joe, the “hard day’s night” movie with the “I’ll cry instead” collage at the beginning was re issued in 1982, not 1986, or perhaps you mean the VHS tape was released in 1986, I’ve still got it!
Along with not a second time vocals this is the best vocal performance of lennon during the first phase of beatles ..
In strictly a musical sense, Lennon is at his best during this period.
I’m curious as to why it was recorded in two parts. Was it to make it easier to adjust the length for the movie? It doesn’t seem like it should have been difficult to play it straight through.
In any case, I’ve always liked this one. Always enjoy hearing it.
Music Critic Al Aronowitz wrote in 1995 that this song was inspired by Bob Dylan, something typically not alleged until discussion of ‘You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away’ written a year later:
It was after listening to Dylan’s first album that John had written his autobiographical “I’ll Cry Instead,” intended for use in the soundtrack of A Hard Day’s Night. The song never made it into the movie, but it very easily could have been written by Dylan about himself. “I’ve got a chip on my shoulder that’s bigger than my feet,” the song said, “I can’t talk to people that I meet.”
Billy Joel did a live cover of this and he released it as the B-side to his hit single “An Innocent Man”.