Written by John Lennon and Paul McCartney in McCartney’s living room in Liverpool, ‘I Saw Her Standing There’ was the opening track on The Beatles’ debut album Please Please Me.
I wrote it with John in the front parlour of my house in 20 Forthlin Road, Allerton. We sagged off school and wrote it on guitars and a little bit on the piano that I had there.
The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, Mark Lewisohn
McCartney is said to have come up with the idea for the song while returning from a concert in Southport, although it was completed with Lennon shortly after in September 1962.
Sometimes we would just start a song from scratch, but one of us would nearly always have a germ of an idea, a title or a rough little thing they were thinking about and we’d do it. ‘I Saw Her Standing There’ was my original, I’d started it and I had the first verse, which therefore gave me the tune, the tempo and the key. It gave you the subject matter, a lot of the information, and then you had to fill in… It was co-written, my idea, and we finished it that day.
Many Years From Now, Barry Miles
The lyrics were written in an exercise book from the Liverpool Institute. Mike McCartney’s book Remember includes a photograph of Paul and John working on the song while reading the book and playing guitars.
We were learning our skill. John would like some of my lines and not others. He liked most of what I did, but there would sometimes be a cringe line, such as, ‘She was just seventeen, she’d never been a beauty queen.’ John thought, ‘Beauty queen? Ugh.’ We were thinking of Butlin’s so we asked ourselves, what should it be? We came up with, ‘You know what I mean.’ Which was good, because you don’t know what I mean.
Anthology
A slightly slower version of ‘I Saw Her Standing There’, believed to have been recorded during a rehearsal at the Cavern Club late in 1962, is available on bootleg recordings. The recording features no rhythm guitar by John Lennon; instead he played harmonica in the introduction and beneath McCartney’s vocals during the verses.
The recording features laughter from McCartney and Lennon as they sing “Well we danced all night/And I held her tight/And I held her hand in mine” during the second bridge.
A live version of ‘I Saw Her Standing There’, recorded on 24 October 1963 in Stockholm during The Beatles’ tour of Sweden, was released on Anthology 1 in 1995. Several other live bootleg versions exist, including two from the Star-Club, Hamburg.
Although it was the lead song on the Please Please Me album in the UK, ‘I Saw Her Standing There’ was first released in the US as the b-side of the ‘I Want To Hold Your Hand’ single, on 26 December 1963.
In the studio
‘I Saw Her Standing There’ was recorded during the marathon session on 11 February 1963, which yielded the majority of tracks on the Please Please Me LP. It was recorded under its working title, ‘Seventeen’.
That’s Paul doing his usual good job of producing what George Martin used to call a ‘potboiler’. I helped with a couple of the lyrics.
The group recorded nine takes in the morning, just three of which were complete. Take one was judged to be the best, and that afternoon The Beatles overdubbed handclaps.
George Martin later edited in McCartney’s spirited “One, two, three, FOUR” count-in from take nine. The full version of take nine can be heard on the ‘Free As A Bird’ single, released in 1995.
McCartney later revealed that his bass guitar part in ‘I Saw Her Standing There’ was lifted from Chuck Berry’s song ‘I’m Talking About You’, a single in February 1961 which The Beatles covered for the BBC on 16 March 1963.
I played exactly the same notes as he did and it fitted our number perfectly. Even now, when I tell people about it, I find few of them believe me. Therefore I maintain that a bass riff doesn’t have to be original.
Many Years From Now, Barry Miles
BBC recordings
The Beatles recorded ‘I Saw Her Standing There’ eleven times for BBC Radio. The first was a live broadcast for the Saturday Club programme on 16 March 1963, and the final recording took place on 1 May 1964 for From Us To You.
A version recorded on 16 October 1963, for the radio show Easy Beat, was first broadcast on 20 October, and was released commercially in 1994 on Live At The BBC.
Another was included on the 2013 collection On Air – Live At The BBC Volume 2. It was recorded for Saturday Club on 7 September 1963 and first broadcast on 5 October
Maybe my favourite “Album one/Side One/ Track One” ever. This song rocks!
John Lennon plays a wonderful and driving rhythm guitar that makes this song FANTASTIC!
an early beatles song. nice lead part by george.
It’s in my top 5 of beatle songs. The rythum, the energy and the guitars make the song great.
Hands down, the best rock ‘n roll song ever recorded.
You are true. TONS of rock songs since this masterpiece of amazing music have been modeled after this entire beat. As timeless as any Beatles song ever.
Unfortunately this masterpiece suddenly doesn’t feel so original to me anymore, since I found out that all the key factors to this song are borrowed. The melody structure of ISHST is nearly identical to ‘When the Saints go Marching In’, the song in their repertoire during time in Hamburg. The overall feeling, tempo, and the driving rhythm guitar are very much the same in these two songs. Plus the base riff from Chuck Berry. What a pity! Still a great song, of course, from the number one band.
“I saw her standing there” a most excellent song came out when I was only 2 years old.I didn’t discover The Beatles until they broke up in 1970 when I was 10 years old.But I heard their music when I was growing up.This song sounds like they captured that time frame of 1963 they were in when it was recorded.Its just that special unique Beatle sound that only they could do.
You are right. If you listen the song that Tony Sheridan recorded with Beatles, you will recognize the same chords and the “uuuhhhh” lyrics.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cDXMPAjdBgE
At 0:13 is the origin of “uuuuuuh” and the chords of “I Saw Her Standing There”.
This is Sheridan’s and the Beatles’ interpretation of When The Saints and strays quite a bit from the original, including changes to the lyrics. The chords are not the same. The driving beat was the signature sound of the Beatles in Hamburg, not Sheridan’s, and heard in My Bonnie and Ain’t She Sweet amongst others.
this may be the best beatle song ever – I think their early hits were the best and this is their first song on their first album
I agree!!!
I don’t think anybody’s debut album first track has ever jumped out the box like this one. You can hear all four parts of the music separately, and even after listening to so much of their work that followed this one, it still stands out as one of their great group performances. It’s one of John’s best rhythm jobs & Paul’s bass drives the entire track. But what jumps out the most is the counter melody in chorus & bridges, Paul going up with John supporting the effort behind him. Add in George’s great solo & Ringo’s intense effort during the solo & you have one of their best songs ever.
i’ve read tha Paul wrote this about Rory Storms sister whom Paul casually dated. she was also a dancer. and this is another reason why personally i love the Beatles Second Lp the best
Most Overrated Beatles Song Ever. An high energy, but ultimately boring, song. They should have given this away to another act.
Well, I think ISHST is an excellent, exciting song. (You can listen to my slightly naughty burlesque by clicking my name above.)
You obviouly underestimate the fact that this song broke through the crap of the day! This being the first song on their first album and Twist and Shout as the last song, made their debut album (On VEEJAY records) totally rock and forced people in the US to notice them.
It is only a matter of taste. For me it is a classic as important as those hits by Little Richard and Carl Perkins’ Blue Suede Shoes. I wonder how old they were when they penned it. I know they completed in 62 but it seems they were still students when they had the idea. They were really born to rock and change the musical world.
I remember reading that Paul was 16 years old.
Jeff Maas,
No, Paul wrote “Love Me Do” when was 16.
Mark Lewisohn is doing a series of 62 short Beatles stories Evolver 62 in October 2022.
Here one – Coincidences
In 1962, Paul McCartney and his girlfriend Cillia decide to hitch down to London to visit Charles Ivan Vaughan. The guy who introduces Paul McCartney with John Lennon on July 6, 1957. Ivan was going to the University of London and was working at The Establishment Club Which Peter Cook open. So, Paul McCartney and his girlfriend got to Club late at night. And The Cabaret starring John Bird, Eleanor Bohn and John Fortune was finish for that night. But Eleanor Bohn who later would star in the movie “Help!” as the lead actress. Paul and Cillia would dance the whole night until The Club was closing its doors. Ivan say’s to Paul that he could spent the night at his place at the Top end Great Portland Street at the Seaford Court. And Mark Lewisohn goes on tells us (coincidence?) that the Asher family use to live at the Seaford Court and that George Martin would learn Oboe lessons from Mrs. Asher. Paul was staying at a place where Jane Asher grew up. Wow! ….That morning in London Paul McCartney decides to write a Song “I Saw Her Standing There”. And Cillia holds that Song to her heart as a treasure.
So, Jeff- Paul McCartney was twenty when he has written “I Saw Her Standing There”.
Sorry Sun King, I usually find myself agreeing with a lot of what you say – but we part company here.
ISHST is an absolutely outstanding rock and roll song – in my opinion, of course.
And when it first came out and hit the US airwaves in ’63, you can be sure NOBODY sounded like this.
In particular, when the middle eight hits “Well me heart went boom” – people are still trying to write transitions like that almost 50 years later.
It’s worth noting that John Lennon, during his solo years, only performed one very old Beatles song live – and this one was it.
Didn’t John perform Come Together at the One To One Concert and Yer Blues at Varsity Stadium in Toronto?
He sang “money” too
so Robert wrote “… very old song…” I agree with him because ISHST is the most amazing rock & roll song of the Beatles’ repertoire… Three songs in this album rocks the first one, the last one and the middle one Boys… and the age is so important… no one in that year made that great sound…
I have always considered this song to be a grand representation of who/what they were before fame set in and had its inevitable effect on them. It sounds like a culmination of youthful, animalistic ardor and the honing brought about by their Hamburg experience. Ar this point they had yet to make their mark, and this track ‘feels’ like they knew they were shortly going to break big
But do you know what bet, and who it was with that took place beforehand that made him agree if he lost the bet he would perform it with this person?
Elton John. Reg bet Lennon that “Whatever Gets You Thru the Night” would become a #1, and when it did, John would have to play live w him and his band. Lennon didn’t see it happening, so he agreed. “I’d like to Elton and the boys for having me up tonight, and we’re going to play one last number so I can get out of here and be sick. Its by an old estranged fiancé of mine called Paul, and it goes like this”:
This was also the night of Lennon’s reconciliation w Yoko and she was there as well (at the invite of EJ?) And I do not recall the date of the concert but Sean was born within the year of this show.
Lennon also said how well his choice of songwriting partners was: “Paul, Yoko, Elton and Bowie. Only the best.”
November 28, 1974. Thanksgiving at Madison Square Garden. It’s available on the Here and There CD (not the original vinyl) which was released in the 1990s. This was also Lennon’s last concert performance, six years before he died. The CD edits out the seven- or eight-minute standing ovation Lennon got when he came out.
There aren’t too many real driving rock n roll numbers penned after the golden age of the fifties, but this one is a true classic and stands up with the best of Berry and Richard. One of George’s best solos too.
John also sang Money, Dizzy Miss Lizzy, Yer blues, Come Together and Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds live as a solo artist.
Yes he did play those live – please re-read what I wrote (caps added for emphasis):
It’s worth noting that John Lennon, during his solo years, only performed ONE VERY OLD Beatles song live – and this one was it.”
yes robert, you are absolutely right; he played it at a concert with Elton John (I think in Madison Square Garden) and he introduced the song as follows: “i would like to do a song now that was written by an old fiancé of mine).
Both Money 1963 and Dizzy Miss Lizzy 1965 are considered old Beatle songs too.
Except Money and Dizzy Miss Lizzie AREN’T Beatle songs. They are Beatle COVER songs. Money was Barrett Strong and Dizzy Miss Lizzie was Larry Williams.
And they were already OLD SONGS before the Beatles ever recorded them.
You might clarify do say 1 McCartney-written Beatles song in his solo career.
In my country (Argentina) the very first Beatles record ever released was the january 1964 single “Twist and shout / I saw her standing there” (even earliest copies were 78 RPM). Can anybody imagine the shock these 2 great rock´n´roll songs produced in a 7 years old kid ? (That was me)
I´ve always wondered why didn´t they choose I Saw Her Standing There for the first single, insetead of Love Me Do. Firstly, because I Saw her Standing There had been already written, and performed live ; secondly, because it´s much more rocking and exciting, than the naive Love Me Do. The lyrics contain some wit , like “and you know what I mean” , the guitar solo is superb, as is Ringo´s drumming. It´s mysterious for me …
Wow!!! Couldn’t sum it up any better…
Absolutely agree with Pablo. I’ve never understood why Love Me Do was chosen as their first single, ISHST is so strong. I guess in the end it didn’t exactly hurt them!
@pablo:
https://www.beatlesbible.com/songs/love-me-do/
If you believe that ISHST was completed in Sep 62, Love Me Do was already recorded at that point (June 62) and decisions to put out something different were probably not easy to make that late in the game. Love Me Do was released on October 5 – they were likely already printing up discs and sleeves at that point. Making a change that late for an unknown group wouldn’t have played well, I’d think.
According to Lewisohn Paul wrote this song only in early Oct.1962 (when in London) and completed it (mostly the lyrics) with John in late Nov. or early Dec. 1962, so too late for the 1st and even the 2nd single.
The Beatles played at the STAR-CLUB Hamburg from 18th to 31st Dec. – with ISHST already in the repertoire (usually as the opener) – and that´s when the live-tapes have been recorded.
@mr. Sun king: to call this song overrated and boring is not a matter of taste but proof of lack of taste and any historical overview (imho). It´s a piece of Rock´n´Roll history and one of the greatest Rock-songs ever written and recorded – one may like it or not.
Probably the BEST rock and roll song ever written. It has everything: Boy meets girl, They fall in love, they dance…and it really rocks. Basic. Timeless. Happy. The perfect dance song.
This is a great rock song. And the live versions do give some sense of how exciting early Beatles live shows would have been.
I have to admit though that I’ve never listened to it quite the same way since it was pointed out how closely the harmonic structure follows When the Saints Go Marching In.
It’s interesting that John sang the highest part of this song (“in miiiiiiine”) with Paul momentarily switching from melody to a lower harmony.
Not sure why they did it that way given it would have been easier for Paul to reach those notes, specially as John had a sore throat when the “Please, Please Me” album was recorded.
Where did you hear that John took the high note on ‘mine’? It sounds like Paul to me.
I met the very woman who this song is written about! Mrs Christmas is her name
wow
Confession: when ‘I want to hold your hand’ was released, I was NOT impressed.
But when the flip side, ISHST started getting regular airplay, I was majorly hooked on the Beatles.
I met my wife at a dance in high school. We were just 17, she stood in front of me and held out her hand. I haven’t danced with another since. This is one of our songs. So timeless, she was born the month after the song was recorded.
one two three FWAH! And history is made.
Absolutely. George Martin’s decision to patch in the 1-2-3-4 count-in from a different take was a master stroke. It grabs your attention and says that what you’re about to hear is something new and exciting (by 1963 standards anyway). Too bad no one told Vee Jay.
What a perfect song.
I love this song! One question though…I noticed in the live versions of ISHST, they go from the guitar solo back to the third verse, while on the recorded version, they go from the solo to the middle eight (“My heart went boom…”) which sounds much better. Any clues from any of the books as to why the recorded version is different? Maybe George Martin wanted the song to last a bit longer and asked them to do the middle eight twice?. It’s such a great live track, but I always miss the 2nd middle eight after the solo, gives the song a real burst of energy after George’s rockin’ solo.
Bill- I agree the second middle eight version is better.
From what I’ve read (I can not remember sources.) the reason they left out the second eight was for the purpose of shortening the song. In those early days pop/rock bands had about 30 minutes max to perform. Acts had to get on and off so the others on the bill could play without the show running very late. With this in mind songs were shortened where possible. It also allowed bands to play more songs with the hope of increasing record sales. Radio stations use to use shortened versions all the time. Depending on the format of a particular station some still do. The Doors ‘Light My Fire’ comes to mind. Back in the day the solo was chopped to the intro and outro. It sounds quite rude.
Once I love a song to hear an edited version destroys the flow of the performance for me.
They did the same thing with both She’s A Woman and Ticket To Ride when played live. Truncated versions.
Harrison’s solo is brilliant! Definitely ahead of the times for then, IMO. Not the usual pentatonics. I have been playing just about ever since that song came out, I have learned many difficult songs and solos by ear, but that solo has a couple of turns that are pretty challenging. And he was just nineteen, know what I mean? (sorry..)
Great choice as an opening track to your first album by The Beatles. A McCartney song with great input by Lennon. Paul McCartney’s vocals are brilliant and others have said a wonderful lead guitar solo by George Harrison.”Please Please Me” is a great debut album, to open with this and close with” Twist and Shout”, breathtaking!!
Does anyone know of a bootleg of this song. (I saw her standing there). I remember listing to Breakfast with The Beatles on 97.1 radio station with host; Deirdre O’Donoghue. Once in a while she would play good gems. And she would always say, “get your tape recorders ready.” She played, I saw here standing there but this one in practiculer was George’s Lead solo. All I remember that it was awful. And you can here John and Paul laughing hysterically. I’m very sure it was during the recording sessions.
I have many bootlegs and all 9 takes of ” I saw her standing there”. But this one in practiculer I can’t find. Does anyone know about this one? Or I’m I wrong on the song?
And by the way, I did get my tape recorder ready but my dumb sister eventually got this one tape and recorded over it.
Was it practiculery annoying?
I just want to say that as great as this song is, the mixer/producer can ruin the song or send it to another level. I refer to the count in edited onto the beginning of the song and the ringing of George’s guitar in the early part of the recording, especially the one chord fill in the second verse after “I’d fall in love with her.” It always sends a chill up my spine when I hear it. One of my top five Beatles songs, if one can narrow down a top five.
Lightning in a bottle. What a powerful way to start a record -and with a brilliant count in. There was nothing like it, and they were off. I generally prefer their later lp’s and songs to their earlier ones, but rank this song right up there with any of my all time favorites.
They still play this song at live sporting events and I never tire hearing it then.
Gabriel – Is it possible that you are mis-remembering hearing Take 1 of A Hard Day’s Night?
Yes, that’s the one I remember, too. John asking George ” What was that?” or something similar.
That was One After 909 from 1963.
I read and loved all the comments about his song and concur that is one of the greatest, if not the greatest, Rock and Roll songs ever. But only 1 person mentioned Ringo’s drumming. I think it is fanatstic!!!
That’s cuz it’s redundant; Ringo’s drumming is ALWAYS fantastic!
McCartney wasn’t as impressed with Ringo’s drumming as you are.
Please elaborate on this claim.
Doesn’t appear that he can. Never heard such a statement or quote.
I personally think and truly believe this is the recording that sky rocketed the Beatles into world stardom. “What a Song”!! All of the Stones, Kinks, Animals and Dave Clark Five never had the raw power to even come close to I Saw Her Standing There. Can I get an Amen..
Amen
What complete and utter tosh!
‘Route 66’ on the first Stones album, ‘Beautiful Delilah’ on the first Kinks album and even ‘Out In The Street’ by The Who on My Generation have just as much if not more clout and energy than ‘I Saw Her Standing There’.
What complete and utter tosh!
None of those songs you mention have the notoriety or impact of this one. None.
Well. MAYBE My Generation comes somewhat close.
First song from the first album
what a phenomenal beginning! Please Please Me and Love Me Do were the 2 bigger hits from the album
but in my opinion this and There’s a Place were the 2 best songs, so full of pure energy..
I’m not sure if I missed something somewhere. I think I read all the comments here. I always wondered why George’s guitar goes from heavy reverb all the way through the solo, then the reverb seems to give way to a dry sound.
Just perfect.
One the most exciting moments in Beatles history.
one two three FOUR!
Ringo’s drumming is superb and his timing is spot on. Pete Best could never play like that.
I know it’s a minor detail, but the correct order of the authors of this track (and a few others from the PPM album) is: McCartney-Lennon.
Love Paul’s revisionist history when he recounts this song… About how he & John “sagged off school” to write it. No, they didn’t. By the time this was written (1962), they already had a recording contract & had been out of school for years.
Every time I play the Vee-Jay pressing of this, with the count-in cut off, I’m reminded of how the count-in to Tony Joe White’s “Polk Salad Annie” is cut off in exactly the same way.
Has anyone noticed/ commented that LIVE – George NEVER played that great Guitar Solo from the original recording? I’ve scoured the internet and haven’t found ONE time (apart from lip-synched versions).
I do agree tho’, one of the all time great songs; just can’t figure why George wouldn’t want to duplicate that intensely perfect Solo (none of the live ones are even close to as good).