Featuring one of John Lennon‘s best vocals on the White Album, ‘Happiness Is A Warm Gun’ was made up of four distinct song fragments, and took its title from a gun magazine, The American Rifleman, which Lennon saw in the studio at Abbey Road.
George Martin showed me the cover of a magazine that said, ‘Happiness is a warm gun’. I thought it was a fantastic, insane thing to say. A warm gun means you’ve just shot something.
Anthology
The first section of the song was made up of phrases thought up by Lennon and Apple’s publicist Derek Taylor during an acid trip the pair experienced along with Neil Aspinall and Lennon’s childhood friend Pete Shotton.
The opening line was a Liverpudlian expression of approval, and the ‘velvet hand’ line was inspired by a fetishist Taylor and his wife met on the Isle of Man.
I told a story about a chap my wife Joan and I met in the Carrick Bay Hotel on the Isle of Man. It was late one night drinking in the bar and this local fellow who liked meeting holiday makers and rapping to them suddenly said to us, ‘I like wearing moleskin gloves you know. It gives me a little bit of an unusual sensation when I’m out with my girlfriend.’ He then said, ‘I don’t want to go into details.’ So we didn’t. But that provided the line, ‘She’s well acquainted with the touch of the velvet hand’.
A Hard Day’s Write, Steve Turner
The lizard on the window pane was a recollection from Taylor’s days living in Los Angeles. The man in the crowd, meanwhile, was from a newspaper report about a Manchester City football fan who had been arrested after inserting mirrors into his footwear in order to see up the skirts of women during matches.
The hands busy working overtime weren’t masturbating, however, but referred to a story heard by Taylor about a man who used false hands as an elaborate shoplifting technique.
The final part of the verse was perhaps the most abstract, but came from earthy origins.
I don’t know where the ‘soap impression of his wife’ came from but the eating of something and then donating it to the National Trust came from a conversation we’d had about the horrors of walking in public spaces on Merseyside, where you were always coming across the evidence of people having crapped behind bushes and in old air raid shelters. So to donate what you’ve eaten to the National Trust was what would now be known as ‘defecation on common land owned by the National Trust.’ When John put it all together, it created a series of layers of images. It was like a whole mess of colour.
A Hard Day’s Write, Steve Turner
The second part of the song (‘I need a fix ’cause I’m going down’) contains Lennon’s clearest reference to heroin while in The Beatles, although he later denied the line was about drugs.
‘Happiness Is A Warm Gun’ was another one which was banned on the radio – they said it was about shooting up drugs. But they were advertising guns and I thought it was so crazy that I made a song out of it. It wasn’t about ‘H’ at all.
Anthology
The double-speed ‘Mother Superior jump the gun’ section, meanwhile, was inspired by his infatuation with Yoko Ono. Mother Superior was a name he used for her, and ‘jump the gun’ could be interpreted as a sexual metaphor.
Oh, well, by then I’m into double meanings. The initial inspiration was from the magazine cover. But that was the beginning of my relationship with Yoko and I was very sexually oriented then. When we weren’t in the studio, we were in bed.
All We Are Saying, David Sheff
An early acoustic version of ‘Happiness Is A Warm Gun’ was recorded at George Harrison‘s home in Esher, Surrey in May 1968. It found Lennon reworking the words and chords of that section, at one point simply singing Ono’s name.
The final part introduces the title phrase over the conventional doo-wop chord sequence (I-vi-IV-V) and a number of changes between 2/4, 3/4 and 4/4 time signatures. The song’s complexity led to The Beatles spending 15 hours and recording 95 takes before being satisfied.
In the studio
On 23 September 1968 The Beatles began recording the song, with the working title ‘Happiness Is A Warm Gun In Your Hand’. They taped the first 45 takes of the song, with John Lennon on lead guitar and guide vocals, Paul McCartney on bass guitar, George Harrison on fuzz lead guitar, and Ringo Starr playing drums.
The following day the group recorded takes 46-70. At the end of these it was decided that the first half of take 53 and the second half of take 65 were the best, and the two were edited together on the evening of 25 September.
With the edit in place, the group began overdubbing later that night. Lennon’s lead vocals were supported by backing vocals from Lennon, McCartney and Harrison. Other additions were an organ, piano, snare drum, tambourine and bass.
During the mixing stage it was decided that the first instance of the ‘I need a fix’ line should be left out. The word ‘down’ can be heard on the final version, however, when the vocals were faded up slightly too early.
you have the time signatures wrong, this is correct:
* She’s not a girl who misses much… (0:00-0:14):
o 4 bars of 4/4.
* She’s well acquainted with the velvet touch… (0:14-0:45):
o 1 bar of 4/4
o 1 bar of 2/4
o 5 bars of 4/4
o 1 bar of 5/4
o 1 bar of 4/4.
* I need a fix cos I’m goin’ down… (0:45-1:13):
o twice through a 3 bars/4 bars/4 bars series of 3/8 (i.e. 22 bars of 3/8).
* Mother superior, jump the gun… (1:13-1:35):
o thrice through a bar each of 9/8 and 10/8.
* Happiness is a warm gun… (1:35-2:43):
o 4 bars of 4/4
o 3 bars of 12/8 (with the drums doing 4 bars of 4/4 and 1 bar of 2/4!)
o 5 bars of 4/4 (the final bar entering free time)
o 1 bar of 2/4 (in free time)
o 5 bars of 4/4
I listened again last night to HIAWG, and I really think that that’s Paul on the drums, he sounds a lot like Ringo, but this is more like Paul, as, say, Birthday and USSR sound like on the White Album. Anyone know for certain?
Paul did not play drums on Birthday. He played drums on Dear Prudence, USSR, overdubbed drums on Lady Madonna (but you can still hear Ringo’s drums with brushes-maybe), but Ringo definitely plays the drums on HIAWG and Birthday.
Both drum tracks on Lady Madonna was Ringo.
The only track where only Paul played drums was on The Ballad of John and Yoko
It’s well-documented that he also played them on USSR and Dear Prudence, during the brief period that Ringo quit the band and went out on Peter Sellers’ yacht.
The songs Paul played drums on: https://web.archive.org/web/20200320223356/http://www.feelnumb.com/2009/03/05/beatles-songs-that-paul-mccartney-played-the-drums/
Just took a listen and heard that the first “I need a fix..” which was edited out by turning down the sound, then bringing the level up was slightly messed up because you can hear the ending “…down” before the “I need a fix…” comes in. Sure enough, it is only a mistake in the stereo and not the mono mix. The Beatles themselves along with George Martin all worked on the mono mixes and they are more tightly edited and correct.
BTW, if you happen to have a bootleg of Happiness from the bootleg album Alternates volume 2, take a listen and you can hear the organ prominently throughout much more of the song. I can see why they would have wanted it out for the most part, it crowds the sound of the song too much. I am still not sure if it is an outfake, but after reading this, I think it might not be.
The organ is still there. If you listen in the very beginning, you can hear it behind johns guitar. In that outtake you can hear it a lot better but they definitely didn’t delete it, it’s just turned way down. I personally like it. It thickens up the guitar part a lot and also adds to the songs darkness
An outfake…LMAO
Yeah, that bit where the song goes into 3 time but the drums stay in 4 time is just insane…
Yeah, that’s an unconscious inspiration for Zeppelin’s Kashmir, imo
During the “When I hold you, in my arms!” part, its hard to figure out. I always thought that Ringo kept playing 4/4 while John, George, and Paul are playing 3/4 over top of Ringo, which leads to a very interesting counter rhythm against each other. I’m pretty sure by the end of it, (Back into the chorus) they actually end up back on the 1 together, which is awesome. They definitely were aware of it too while recording it.
A long time ago, I read that John Kelly, the photographer who shot the four portraits of the four Beatles that came as inserts with the White Album, met with Paul McCartney around the time of finishing that album (presumably to shoot Paul’s portrait). Paul told him to listen to a tape of “Happiness is a Warm Gun.” According to Kelly, McCartney told him something to the extent of “listen to this, it’s the best thing I’ve ever heard.”
Paul, and George, really liked this song. Having multiple tunes, themes, textures, etc., appealed to Paul. I believe this contributed to his later extension of that into his solo work – ‘Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey’, ‘Band On The Run’, ‘Venus And Mars’.
I just read your observation and that is impressive. I think “You Know My Name” came out after the White Album and that may be Paul’s first Beatle foray into that type of song. I suppose “A Day In The Life” preceeded both, but that wasn’t a conscious writing of a song within a song, just 2 that were put together.
You’re right. But it contributed firstly to the extension of that into Abbey Road’s medley. I read it was a clear influence.
Yeah, you didn’t list eletric piano part. There is also organ part (or melletron) in first section.
Where, precisely? I’ve listened closely and cannot hear an organ, electric piano or Mellotron anywhere in this song. There was an organ part recorded along with a piano part, but they were left out of the final mixes.
At the VERY beginning, very quietly, you can sort of here it.
There is an organ or mellotron part that you can hear at the beginning of the mono mix. It is either very low or not included in the stereo mix. On the mono mix, it is most audible just after the first line “She’s not a girl who misses much.”
At the very END, I can hear something that sounds like a keyboard : when John sings his last “warm gun mama”, there is a sort of trill (the notes c and d played alternatively very fast during the F chord, and then the notes b and c during the G chord). It’s on the right channel (the same as the guitar solo).
According to the session logs there was even a tuba used but it is so buried in the mix that it is virtually unheard.
Hey Joe… there is in fact an Organ through out the first 2 passages of the song… “She’s not a girl” and “She’s well acquainted” … Through out the “She’s not a girl” part The organ is playing a counter point arpeggio/melody type part against John’s Arpeggiated chordal intro… Then during the “She’s well acquainted” part they are playing whole note chords against the guitars… It’s definitely there, and is more prominent in the remastered version… There is also a video on Youtube of an abbey road booth mix that has the organ turned up VERY loud. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFvi3aqOg64 …. This is a solo track of the Organ but it gives you what exactly is happening over the first 2 parts… This part IS on the final result and WAS not scrapped…. you just have to listen VERY hard and you will notice it is there
There’s a piano playing straight quarter note chords in the final section, “Happiness is a warm gun, mama….”
Is it true that Chris Thomas played on this?
Also, is there any specific reason that George Martin did not produce the song?
I’m not aware of Chris Thomas playing on it. He produced the song – and several other White Album ones – because George Martin was on holiday.
thanks for the info!! 😀
any idea why they chose him to produce? he was only hired as an errand boy, if what i read is true…
sry for all these questions, its just i cant seem to find much info on the subject
I don’t think he was hired as an errand boy. He was GM’s assistant, so was probably mentored by him with a view to becoming a producer himself. Either way he was a talented musician and went on to produce in his own right (ie not as GM’s stand-in).
Chris Thomas received a £36 bonus registered as four keyboard session fees, according to Billboard (March 6, 1993), p. A-22. That would be harpischord on Piggies, Mellotron on The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill, Piano on Long, Long, Long and Harpsichord on Not Guilty. So, I conclude, he did not play on HIaWG.
I guess John starts playing guitar with his fingers (arpeggios), and then takes his plectrum in the gap between “I need a fix cos’ I’m going down…” and “Mother superior…”.
Anyway, that’s how I have to do if I want to play his part “as it is”.
I can’t think of any others songs where he does this. Am I wrong?
I guess in “Dear Prudence” he does; at least in the Escher demo he does (while the official released version has so many overdubs it’s not so obvious)
This has got to be one of my favorite Lennon tracks–ever. I think his vocals were great, and the music is interesting. As for the lyrics, I never really looked into it all that much, mainly becuase they probably would have some drug influence.
You don’t get into the lyrics if they may have drug implications? Boy oh boy you must have trouble listening to their ’66-’67 output
No. I know what most of their songs are about at those times–and that drugs influenced them. And I obviously know that they took drugs. It’s just, I try not to emphasize on that, and just enjoy the music as a whole. I think I worded this weirdly, but I hope you get what I mean.
There is an organ in the beginning. It blends very smoothly with Lennon’s appegio guitar. The Piano was in the chorus in the end of the song but it was wiped in the mix.In some of the bootlegs of the song, you can hear it clearly.
Interesting reading Derek Taylor’s account of what the lyrics were on about…
I always felt ‘the donation to the National Trust’ involved something other than a sculpture!
I always wondered because they ate then they donate. Sounds pretty clear.
I am sure that the ‘childs’ voice towards the end of this track is Yoko. I read it some where a long time ago and if you listen to it again there is a hint of a japanese accent. Surprised she isn’t listed on this page.
I thought ‘donated to the national trust, was a reference to Across the Universe (about Cynthia) which was actually donated to the national trust hence the flock of birds at the start of the rarities track.
Harrison’s solo is the greatest (as far as “feel”) that I have ever heard in my life hands down!
ditto!!! George is a stud. He delivers. If u had a thoroughbred mare that someone said you had only one chance at conception…one time to get the deed done…you would bring in George. This is a musical metaphor but still if you use your imagination I think u will get it.
You are on the money, Bobby Scotland. He certainly held his own and did his job. You can tell he just loved playing this lick.
I’m pretty Sure that Solo is John… even says on the actual page on this website… and it DEFINITELY sounds like a clunky John Solo
you mean the guitar lick after the “national trust” – that’s john!? i always thought that was George though….how do you know it’s john?
the one followed by ‘i need a fix’ ……
I’ve heard this song 100+ x’s. I firmly believe that the fuzz solo the soft finger in the intro the regular rhythm and the low rhythm on the right speaker with that trippy off note..ALL of these are Lennon. The lead has an exact style of that low rhythm guitar on this Lennon masterpiece. I also believe that ALL vocals are Lennon as well.
Back on the guitars on this Lennon masterpiece…I now feel that ALL guitars as well as ALL vocals were Lennon. When the cat George Mi s away lennon will play. The finger intro is Lennon obviously the biting rhythm next and the deep rhythm in Mother S. But the fuzz lead is very similar to that deep rhythm style. Since George H isn’t going just sit there and watch let’s assume Georgey was playing the lead. Likewise Paul. No real noticeable contribution cept that incredible walk up he does “bits that I’m left of”. All Lennon here and the band sat back and gawked
This site is new for me, I’m from Argentina and I’ve just discovered it, thank you for so much information!
I was always intrigued about the last shout “Guuuuuuun!!!” of this song. Is that Lennon? I think that the tone is so high that maybe it was sung by McCartney, despite it sounds strange. I’m a Beatles fan since I was a little boy and I’m pretty sure that that tone and the beginning of “Mr. Moonlight” are the highest-pitched achieved by Lennon with a clear voice (that means, not distorted or broken like in Twist and Shout and those rock’n’roll songs). The “gun” in this song is even higher than Mr. Moonlight’s, it’s amazing if John could really get that tone.
Thank you!
Hi there! I’m quite sure it’s John, singing falsetto. I guess he was just on a roll when they recorded that – the whole vocal ist just so… awe-inspiring.
Anyone know what instrument is playing after the line “a soap impression of his wife, which he ate and donated to the National trust?” What is that?
It is a distorted guitar. Great string bends. The distortion may be from the amp cranked way up coupled with a direct line to the mixing desk for extra “tone/fuzz. The opening of Revolution was done in this fashion too.
Off the hat I can think of two more songs featuring John’s falsetto voice; there’s a high note in “I Should Have Known Better” and a whole phrase in “Tell Me Why”.
And, of course, “You’re Gonna Lose That Girl”. I bet there are more..
In the stereo version at least, you can hear another attempt to hit that note just a moment before the final one, and very faintly.
I’m writing a song-by-song blog on the Beatles (in spanish, sorry) and run after every single piece of information. But there’s something even greater. Let me tell you. My 12-years-old son became crazy about “Happiness…” about two weeks ago. Yesterday he started saying: “Dad… the very last sound of this song is exactly the same as another Beatles song ending”. I didn’t appreciate too much his words for the first hundred times… But finally I sighed, put my brain on it and… My God! It’s “She loves you”. Can’t you hear it? I’m so very proud!!!
That’s because they use the same word and end on a major 6th.
Way cool swann! Congratulations to your alert boy. I love that a 12-year-old gets enraptured by Beatles music.
Does anyone have footage/ a video of them singing this live?
Dude, They NEVER did it live. It was recorded 2 years after they’ve finished touring.
Hello
You don’t mention who plays the piano, yet a piano there is in this song (electric piano)
I wonder about the electric piano in the part “I need a fix … ” John or Paul ? Did anybody find out how John imitates Mick Jagger in the last verse ? (Especially while singing “When I hold you in my arms … ” Great Lennon
In France, many books tell that this song talks about oral sex. I listened to the song thousands of times and still can’t understand why, maybe because i’m from southern france. Could anyone confirm and tell me please??
Could be the way the word hap-PI-ness is enunciated
My opinion – John just loved the way words sounded. He played with them for the lyrical effect rather than the actual meaning. It’s evident from his book, Spaniard in the Works. HIAWG is up there with Walrus and Strawberry Fields as one of John’s great songs.
“Going down” on a woman is slang for oral sex.
There´s an electric piano, for sure, in “I Need a Fix” part. Is very straight and simple, and I think John played it.
That’s John’s rhythm guitar. George is actually playing the distorted guitar in the right channel, along with the fuzz toned lead guitar in the middle (overdubbed).
I also believe it’s John who plays it
Does anyone else think that he’s really saying ‘happiness is a warm girl’ in the last section when he sings ‘happiness is a warm gun’? I mean, he sings it in a real, well, passionate way, and that line ‘when I hold you in my arms’… you don’t hold a gun in your arms, you hold a girl in your arms, you hold a gun in your hands! And the other sexually-themed lines all through the song, it just seems appropriate….
I’d much rather hold a girl anyway, I’m sure John would agree with me!
There is also a bass part that is from a vocalization, much like what’s done in “I Will”. Both cases sound like Paul.
Hi
Having been a bit of a Beatles fanatic since they were still in existence, and having considered myself a bit of an expert on them, I’m pretty impressed with some of the stuff you’re coming out with, makes me feel like an amateur.
Firstly in answer to David Annderson, I’ve always been of the opinion that he’s really meaning ‘happiness is a warm girl’, not just in the last section, but all through the entire song.
On the subject of the keyboards, this is from Wikipedia.
“While officially uncredited, Chris Thomas (the track’s producer) has stated that he provided the keyboards for the track.”
Finally as a season ticket holder at Manchester City for many years, it’s quite amusing to find out that the man with the multicolour mirrors on his hobnail boots, was quite possibly in the same crowd as me.
I hear a keyboard ( before ” I need a fix “. Who plays this keyboard ?
That’s John’s rhythm guitar.
Someone needs to check out what songs Nicky Hopkins played with the Beatles.He is listed in his site that he played on LOTS of songs startin with SPLHCB
Just listened to this intently with headphones on. There is most definitely a piano or keyboard part. Sound more like like a piano. It happens during the “Happiness is a warm gun” part. Who plays it?
My bet is on Paul, since he liked to fiddle in keyboard parts for John’s songs. The organ is probably Lennon.
I absolutely love George’s guitar in this song. The little solo before the “I need a fix” bit is incredible. The string bends and timing, it’s just a soulful little lick. He really felt it with this one!
If I could take only one Beatles song to a desert island…it’s warped and brilliant.
Whatever the meaning, a brilliant song that John Lennon could only have written. The way the song changes and Lennon’s vocals are wonderful. One of many great songs off “The White Album”.
I spent more than a few years of my youth obsessing over this song. During my mix tape phase, I’d use lyric snippets as tape titles: Lizard on a Windowpane; Warm Gun Yeah!; A Soap Impression; Bang Bang Shoot Shoot; Not a Girl Who Misses Much; Velvet Hand; Multi-Color Mirrors. And so on. So 13-year old me (my age when the album came out) puzzled and puzzled over the “Soap Impression” line — nonsense or not? I finally realized what happens if you eat soap — you’re bound to “donate” it somewhere. I always thought that “National Trust” was a turn of phrase similar to “Public Domain,” which is where your donation ends up, metaphorically, sooner or later. To find out that the reference was a bit more literal than I thought cracked me up! My favorite White Album song!
One of my all time Beatles favorites!
actually, only the stereo mix has the slight mistake where the vocal was faded in too early, and you can hear the word “down”. the mono mix is correct and doesn’t have that.
Great song from the start to the end. Playing it and making it sound right it is just lots of fun! Love the lyrics melody.
Back in the beginning days of discovering The Beatles through dad buying The Beatles Rock Band on Xbox 360, he played me this and Hey Jude another time in the car. One of my first introductions outside of the game (the game obviously has a very short catalog across The Beatles as a band). Can’t remember my thoughts on it the first time, but I’m pretty sure I was taken away.
This is who played what according to beatlesebooks.com
John Lennon – Lead and Background Vocals, Rhythm Guitar (1965 Epiphone ES- 230TD Casino), Organ (Hammond RT-3)
Paul McCartney – Bass (1964 Rickenbacker 4001 S), Piano (Hamburg Steinway Baby Grand), tuba, backing vocals
George Harrison – Lead Guitar (1961 Sonic Blue Fender Stratocaster, painted psychedelic), backing vocals
Ringo Starr – Drums (1964 Ludwig Super Classic Black Oyster Pearl), tambourine
That’s correct. Paul played two basslines in this song, though, one on the Höfner bass and another on the Rick.
These were the best vocals Lennon ever sang.
Curiously this track was omitted on at least one version of the album. My friend brought the LP back from the far east around 1970. I didn’t realise the song existed until I bought the sheet music book shortly after. Imagine my puzzlement at seeing this unexpected and unusual song (the sheet music gives no clue as to how extraordinary it sounds).
Among ‘Cred-Heads’ (people who appreciate the Incredible String Band) there’s a strong belief that this song was partly inspired by Robin Williamson’s ‘Mad Hatter’s Tea Party’ on the 1967 LP The 5000 Spirits. It’s a song with a similar structure: diverse fragments which go together to make up a whole.
Funny how Lennon complained about spending a lot of time on certain McCartney songs, yet he was willing to spend 15 hours and 95 takes on this meaningless tripe.
Yeah but the McCartney tracks weren’t worth the effort – this one was, and the whole band generally felt that way about Lennon’s songs. It was to create true “Beatle-music” (to use John’s phrase) when they worked for days on a Lennon song like Strawberry Fields or Happiness Is a Warm Gun, whereas McCartney’s commandeering of studio time for, say, Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da or Maxwell’s Silver Hammer was to create McCartney-music. That’s the big difference, and it’s why Harrison and Starr were excited to play on Lennon’s work, even occasionally, into the early ’70s.
If only John had spent less time on meaningless tripe and more time on songs about English sheepdogs.
At least English Sheepdogs are SOMETHING, not thrown-together drivel.
I need a fix cuz I’m going down,
Back to the bitch that I left uptown …
I’ve always heard the words this way.
If you imagine (sorry) John’s state of mind at the time,
you can understand why he might have said it.
It’s interesting that no one remembers the cover of the legendary gun magazine with any accuracy. There’s no smoking gun or any mention of the so-called “lead” article titled “Happiness Is A Warm Gun” (actually an insignificant one-page reminiscence about rifles and shotguns on page 21). Trivial, yes, but it makes me wonder what else they got wrong.
Does anyone know who played the sax when John is singing ‘I need a fix cause I’m going down’? I can’t find any particular credits on this song for that instrument.
It’s a distorted guitar and not a sax.
Fantastic article and I always thought of myself as a “Anorak” but you all put me to shame!!
The very ending reminds me of the ending of “In My Life”. Something of a doo-wop trope. I like how it works in both songs.
You’re all right… It was about sex, and drugs, and was most definitely rock and roll!