The first song on 1965’s Rubber Soul album, ‘Drive My Car’ reversed the traditional boy-girl roles in The Beatles’ songs, presenting a tale of a gold digger and wannabe star who wants a man as a chauffeur and for sexual services.
Paul McCartney‘s first draft of the song featured a chorus based around the line, “You can buy me golden rings”. He and John Lennon reworked the song with some difficulty, eventually discarding the clichés and settling upon the idea of a headstrong woman.
The lyrics were disastrous and I knew it… This is one of the songs where John and I came nearest to having a dry session. The lyrics I brought in were something to do with golden rings, which is always fatal. ‘Rings’ is fatal anyway, ‘rings’ always rhymes with ‘things’ and I knew it was a bad idea. I came in and I said, ‘These aren’t good lyrics but it’s a good tune.’ The tune was nice, the tune was there, I’d done the melody. Well, we tried, and John couldn’t think of anything, and we tried and eventually it was, ‘Oh let’s leave it, let’s get off this one.’ ‘No, no. We can do it, we can do it.’ So we had a break, maybe had a cigarette or a cup of tea, then we came back to it, and somehow it became ‘drive my car’ instead of ‘gold-en rings’, and then it was wonderful because this nice tongue-in-cheek idea came and suddenly there was a girl there, the heroine of the story, and the story developed and had a little sting in the tail like ‘Norwegian Wood’ had, which was ‘I actually haven’t got a car, but when I get one you’ll be a terrific chauffeur.’
Many Years From Now, Barry Miles
The song contained clear sexual overtones, from the first verse’s “You can do something in between” to the suggestive promises of “a better time”.
’Drive my car’ was an old blues euphemism for sex, so in the end all is revealed. Black humour crept in and saved the day. It wrote itself then. I find that very often, once you get the good idea, things write themselves.
Many Years From Now
The arrangement was suggested by George Harrison, who had been listening to Otis Redding’s ‘Respect’, then a minor hit. Harrison suggested that the bass and guitar parts should play similar lines in an approximation of Redding’s bass-heavy sound, resulting in one of The Beatles’ most effective performances of 1965.
I helped out such a lot in all the arrangements. There were a lot of tracks though where I played bass. Paul played lead guitar on ‘Taxman’, and he played guitar – a good part – on ‘Drive My Car’.We laid the track because what Paul would do, if he’s written a song, he’d learn all the parts for Paul and then come in the studio and say, ‘Do this.’ He’d never give you the opportunity to come out with something. But on ‘Drive My Car’ I just played the line, which is really like a lick off ‘Respect’, you know, the Otis Redding version – and I played that line on guitar and Paul laid that with me on bass. We laid the track down like that. We played the lead part later on top of it.
Crawdaddy
The 2006 album Love mixed ‘Drive My Car’ with extracts from ‘The Word’ and ‘What You’re Doing’, together with guitar solo from ‘Taxman’ and horns from ‘Savoy Truffle’.
In the studio
‘Drive My Car’ was recorded on 13 October 1965. The session began at 7pm and ended at 12.15am – The Beatles’ first to end after midnight.
The group took some time to perfect the arrangement for ‘Drive My Car’. Although they recorded four takes of the rhythm track, only the last of these was complete.
The basic arrangement had Paul McCartney on bass guitar, George Harrison playing guitar – contradicting his Anthology recollections – John Lennon on tambourine, and Ringo Starr on drums. The group then overdubbed piano, lead guitar, piano and cowbell parts, along with lead vocals by Lennon and McCartney, and backing vocals by Harrison.
There was always some confusion about who played bass, because Harrison said he played the bassline. But you have to know, he never actually spoke of playing bass! His quote from the Anthology has been taken out of context, the whole quote is as followed:
“I just played the line, which is really like a lick off [Donald “Duck” Dunn’s part for Otis Redding’s ‘Respect’, September 1965] and I played that line on the guitar and Paul laid that with me on bass” (Growing up at 33 1/3: The George Harrison interview, 1977).
The basic track of the recording appears on the left channel of the final mix:
drums (Ringo), tambourine (John), bass (Paul), guitar (George)
Onto this, overdubs were recorded, first the main vocal track with Lennon-McCartney leads and backing from Harrison (center on cd, right channel on vinyl).
The third track has only Lennon’s double-tracked vocal for “and maybe I’ll love you” and “beep”s (second ending and coda). This track appears on the left channel.
The fourth track (right channel) features continuous cowbell, McCartney’s guitar (which doubles Harrisons guitar in the intro and takes the solo and coda) plus Lennon on piano. (The record sleeve says “Paul on piano” but that’s wrong. In the coda, you can hear Paul’s guitar and the piano (plus cowbell) playing at the same time and they all were recorded on one track.
That is confusing. The quotation from George in Anthology wasn’t taken out of context – it was from the interviews conducted for the television series and the book. Where historical quotations were used (and can be seen most commonly with John Lennon’s sections) small numbers detail the year in which they were said – this is explained in the book’s Editorial Note at the start.
As George’s claim to the bass part of Drive My Car doesn’t have a number alongside it, I think it’s safe to say it’s his actual words, in context, from the 1990s. It contradicts the 1977 interview, of course. I guess memory may have been at fault somewhere along the line. But thanks for the track-by-track breakdown – I’ll amend the line-up.
I think even in the Anthology he is only speaking of playing “the bassline”, not playing the instrument bass.
Hi, SD:
I’ve been reading your comments on this site, and your facts (or information) seems pretty interesting and pretty accurate, where did you get it?
At first I thought you were quoting Walter Everett book, but some facts are different (i. e., Everett says Paul plays piano on this one and you claim it is John, actually).
SD gets information from his head I believe. Paul plays piano, without a doubt, not John.
I think this all all spot on, except that to my ears George’s guitar part starts with the bass-line riff. I think only Paul is playing the opening guitar solo, in the right channel. But it spills over into the left channel, partly because of the reverb chamber return, which is mixed in the center; hence it sounds a bit like like a double. However, the double is too exact in my opinion to have been actually played; in addition, you can hear the first note of George’s bass-line riff clearly as the start of a new part.
This song was Paul’s baby. John helped on the lyrics,and sang the low harmony on verses ,and the “and baby Ill love you “ — Could never understand why they didn’t throw in “and maybe I’ll love you “ on the second round. Plus Tamborine.
Musically.
The intro, and solo ( The slide works so well on last couple of bars ) are both Paul. The piano is Paul. The bass is Paul,and the lead vocal – melody – is Paul.
John as mention above .
George ,just the riff,and beeps beeps vocally.
Ringo drums ,and cowbell.
There is a dropout in the original 65 UK stereo pressing. All you hear is Paul-John ,and a cowbell on right side. I play everything Paul plays, and you can tell when it’s him, and not George. Paul has a lot of passion in his guitar playing, and the intro doesn’t sound anything like George ,and you have to know Paul arranged it. Just listen to where the bass comes in on intro to song. This was obviously all in Paul’s head at the time. It’s possible I imagine that Paul could have shown George the opening riff ,and I would make sense to get the feel for the timing on the bass. McCartneys solo has a wide stretch on the intervals ,and a lot of bends bringing notes up. Paul’s timing is all feel, that’s why his solos are so in your face ,and just happen to be melodic ,as well as creative. That’s part of what made the Beatles so great. Each played to their strengths ,and each had an entirely different feel, and innate ability. George was a late bloomer. Don’t get me started on how screwed he got on Abbey Road. George had three great songs that could have replaced at least two songs by John. I have always maintained that Abbey Road should have been THEE double album. All three writers had completed songs that never saw the light of day as Beatles songs. Isn’t it a pity …
“Drive My Car” was also available on the “Yesterday…and Today” album.
SD, I think the “maybe i love you line” is sung in unison by paul and john. WHY? Because until revolver they didn’t have the luxury of the adt (artificial double tracking) so if that vocal part was recorded in only one track, i dont see how john could posible sings two vocals parts live.
Paul and John both sang almost every line together with George joining in for the chorus. The only line someone sang solo was “maybe I’ll love you” by John. Check the harmony vocals on The Beatles: Rock Band if you don’t believe me. I’m quite sure they had double-tracking in 1965.
“Maybe I love you” is John on the right track – and GEORGE on the left track. Been checking it out all day in ‘phones.
I heard Paul’s voice on “Maybe i love you”. And i didn’t heard George, maybe in the chorus, but it’s so lower… the lower harmony it’s John, that’s sure.
its john and paul
Yes they had double tracking in 1965, but until revolver they hadn’t artificial (automatic) double tracking. So until revolver, if they wanted double tracked vocals (which they used it a lot in the early records) they had to record the vocals twice, and for that they needed two tracks. And “the maybe i love you” vocals were recorded in one track. For better explication go to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_double_tracking
¿So Paul can’t play piano and lead guitar at same time because are recorded in one track, but john can sing two vocals parts at the same time?
Now you have to check again drive my car harmony vocals in rock band because the video shows that Paul sings too the “maybe i love you” line.
In fact the only mistake that the rock band did is show George singing with paul in the drive my car verses and not john.
Guys – what you are all maybe missing here is that they were also able to ‘bounce’ tracks – ie record on 3 tracks and then mix down to the 4th and so on – so its perfectly possible to double track vocals and play more than one part etc
Yes! After all, Les Paul & Mary Ford we’re doing it all in the 1950’s!….
Also am I the only person to ever notice
( on the ORIGINAL recording) of drive my car
Pauls bass was way out of tune on certain notes?
All the postings on YouTube are 2009 remasters which appear to have been corrected!
All of you seems to know quite a lot about The Beatles. But I’m not sure that you really feel the music.
I really can’t understand how you can consider that its Paul who sings “and maybe I love you”. Even wilder is the theory, that its Paul and John. Common! Its George who sings that line. No doubt at all.
I hear both of them… George and John…
I heard a loid “maybe i love you” of Paul…
I hear Mal Evans and Neil Aspinall.
No, no, no, no, no, no, it´s either George Martin and Brian Epstein or Patti Boyd and Jane Asher.
Seriously, it is John in the left channel and Paul in the right. No doubt about it, no doubt about it.
That “And maybe I love you” line is a good example of what a unique and fantastic voice John had, on occasions strained, yet controlled and full-bodied.
Paul´s hoarse voice here is also one of the best.
jaaa, well so it’s George, Day tripper . I love the beatles music, we are only discussing here for fun, and I feel the music, that’s why I like to talk about it.
Returning to the “maybe I love you” discussion, I think I gave a pretty good explanation why ” the maybe I love you” line is sung by paul and john in unison and not john double tracked. It’s not a crazy theory, you know.
Again, there is no room for a discussion, no room for a theory. Its George, who sings “and maybe I love you”, no matter what would be possible. Just listen to it, you can hear it.
Hi Day Tripper, I grew up listening to Beatles records very attemptively, since I was 6 (and I’m 43 now) and I’m more than willing to back you up on this. For me, it’s clear that the verse “and maybe I’l love you” is sung by John and George. Really no evidence of Paul’s voice on that. Even George’s voice is clearer than John’s. So that would also solve the double-track question as well.
John and Paul sing the “and maybe i’ll love you” line; it’s not a matter of what’s right and wrong, it’s just factually correct. Paul is on the right channel, John is on the left when you listen in the headphones.
It’s John & Paul with an emphasis on John singing “and maybe I’ll love you…”
Day Tripper be trippin’! John’s voice is unquestionably the most prominent, and George can’t be heard at all.
Yes, Day Tripper be trippin’ indeed. I hear Paul the most clearly when the song is playing, but any sane person can tell it’s multiple voices. If your computer has the ability to control the balance on your speakers, mute the left side of the audio and you will clearly hear Paul sing this line by himself. If you mute the right side, the vocals aren’t as prominent in the mix but what is clear is that it is Paul singing the same line on a separate track, and it also sounds like someone else (most likely John) is singing the line with him. You can listen to all of Rubber Soul this way for a very rewarding listen. Since the whoever mixed the stereo version panned all instruments and vocals completely to one side or the other. I promise you you will hear things you never noticed before.
I agree that it is Paul singing, And maybe I’ll love you. At least that’s what I’ve heard for the last 55 years
Paul´s voice is heard a bit louder in the right channel than John´s in the left.
Okok…but anybody can tell me,the right verse?
And maybe I love you or
And maybe I’ll love you.
Thanks.
I always heard it as “maybe I’ll love you” as in … then, after you drive my car, maybe we’ll make love. That’s consistent with the rest of the lyrics.
According to Anthology, “you can by me diamond rings” was the original line—but they balked at that. You’ve got to admit, “baby you can drive my car” is more unique than “baby you can buy me diamond rings”.
The Anthology book says golden rings, not diamond ones. McCartney says the same in Many Years From Now. I’ve never read an original source where either Lennon or McCartney mention diamond rings.
Sgt Pepper, you’re thinking of lyrics to Can’t Buy Me Love
This is one track that absolutely KILLS in mono. Blows the stereo version(s) away.
Regarding your comment about “Drive My Car” in mono—I agree with you except I think MANY songs really shine in monaural. Listening to “Producing The Beatles” podcast ( Jason Krupps production) about George Martin’s work with the Fab4, I think part of it is that he made them sound like the live band that they were. A blast of sound is exciting in minaural and certain early Beatles up till mid 60s can sound good transmitted in mono depending on each recording of course.
It definately is not George who sings that line, it just sounds like Lennon, but it is most likely that they sung it together (John + Paul)
Hi everyone
Does anybody know if the beep beep in the song resembles with the beetle horn?
I think so. But maybe anyone here knows better, hope so.
thanks and God bless this place and the band to wich is devoted.
Love
So George played bass…?
could john have sung ‘and maybe I love you’ twice and had a reduction mix to put it in the same track as his other vocal?
‘and maybe I love you’ is sung by John & George, I have no doubt. And the harmony along the main melody is sung by Paul & Paul, doubletracking his voice of course, up to “but you can do…” “but I found a driver…”,etc. where John & George add their voices.
The Drive my Car ” Maybe I love you” line is sung by Paul and John in unision according to this very detailed beatles website of the recording of Drive my Car:
https://www.beatlesebooks.com/drive-my-car
The following text about Drive my car is taken of that website:
“The chorus , which is also eight measures in length, then begins with the entrance of Paul’s piano being the most notable additional element. The piano plays the part of a rhythm instrument in the absence of the usual strummed guitar as in nearly every other Beatles song up to this point. Uniquely, the piano plays a slow triplet pattern in the second and fourth measures as a nice contrast against the uniform 4/4 rhythm that continues underneath it. (The group decides to reprise the use of triplets, per George Harrison’s suggestion, on “We Can Work It Out” which began recording a week later.)
While the cowbell and accented tambourine enter the picture again in the chorus, a second tambourine also comes in to shake a steady rock beat with the drums. John and Paul continue to harmonize throughout this section except for the final phrase “and baby I love you” which is sung in unison, Paul on the right channel and John as overdubbed afterward on the left channel. The piano plays its final chord of the chorus on the one-beat of the eighth measure, leaving behind the guitar and bass unison Otis Redding-like riff to fill out the rest of the final measure.
I’ll definitely agree with Day Tripper, no matter what such and such good book says, we can clearly hear George singing ‘and maybe I’ll love you’, along with Paul who has no logical reason to stop singing at this point !
The verses are sung by Paul & John (sorry Carlos, can’t be double-tracked Paul, the tones of the voices are obviously different). One listen at the one not-so-synchronized line ‘and she said listen babe I got something to say’ should be enough to silence ANY theory against it, brothers !
As for the piano, sounds more like Paul’s style than John’s (especially those bluesy triplets).
The “and maybe I love you” is sung by Paul and JOHN. You can hear his nasal voice very well if you turn up only your left channel.
I really can’t figure out who’s doing the second vocal in the verse. But it’s definitely not impossible that it’s both Paul.
I’m afraid not ! I happened to find this on Youtube yesterday, please take a listen.
Paul definitely sings the verses with John, I have no problem with distinguishing John´s, Paul´s and George´s voices from each other..
No, check this video: https://www.ajournalofmusicalthings.com/more-fun-with-isolated-vocals-the-beatles-and-drive-my-car/
Just in case anybody comes across this page’s comments and is hopelessly confused, let’s get one thing straight. The “and maybe I’ll love you” lines in “Drive My Car” are John and Paul. Dig out the ORIGINAL stereo mix, with the majority of the vocals present on the right channel. On the left, John’s voice sings the only solo vocal line present. On the right, that same line is most definitely sung by Paul. (If anything, PAUL on the right sounds more like George, even though it’s not.)
If you can’t hear that, go and listen to the “ah” section of A Day In The Life and try to figure that one out. :p
Well, much confusion on this one ! First of all, Paul and John sing all the song together, including “and maybe I´ll love you”, as George just does the harmony parts in the last sentence of each verse and in the refrain, with the exception of “maybe I´ll love you ” .
And I don´t know why would someone put a wrong information on the album : it´s Paul who plays the piano ! George plays both the basic riff guitar and the solo , in my opinion. Let´s remember that the details contained in both Help and Rubber Soul album sleeves have the same logic : just to point out what is different of the original Beatles’ line-up : Paul on bass, George on lead, John on rhythm and Ringo on drums. For example, in Another Girl, it´s stated that Paul is playing lead guitar, like in Ticket to Ride, so we shouldn´t doubt it. If Paul palyed the solo on Drive My Car, most probably it would be written on Rubber Soul´s sleeve. I think that the basic track was as it was mentioned above : Paul on bass, George on guitar, John on tambotine. For the overdubs, Paul played piano, George played the lead guitar, John played cowbell and Ringo, maracas. That is the most probable line-up for this track !
I definitely agree with you, Pablo Castro. Besides for the guitar solo there are too,many bended notes and bending is not what I’d range among Paul’s guitar skills. And that’s quite natural for him anyway, ’cause basically he’s a bass player
When I listen to either the isolated vocals or the full track, I hear Paul’s voice being the high part in the 2-part verse, in the 3-part end-of-verse, and the chorus (just as everyone else seems to). I hear the low voice on the verse (singing C’s and B’s) going on to be the low voice in the 3-part end of verse (on a C) and on the chorus (a monotone pedal B). And I hear a new voice joining as the middle part at the end of the verse (an F) and on the chorus, paralleling Paul’s part a third down.
It seems like most of you hear the middle part as being George and the lower part as being John but to me it sounds more like the middle one is John, especially on the 3-part end-of-verse (e.g. “But you can do something in between”). But that would make it Paul + George on the 2-part sections. Anyone else hear it like that?
This is a killer track, full stop.
Is it only me, or is anybody else trying to find the version of “drive my car” which has the addition of a horn section during the chorus? I can’t find a mention of it anywhere but I know it exists as I’ve heard the version played on the Radio!
That is a remixed version from the “Love” album. It’s basically a mash up -the horns were originally on “Savoy Truffle”
George played the “bassline” on his Fender strat utilizing the neck pickup. Maybe split between the neck and middle pickup. That tone from the strat really brings out clean bass tones.
Your assessment sounds fair enough, but if you are relying on Harrison’s claims to playing the bass-line during the Anthology project (which of course have been called into question), how exactly does it prove that the claim is true? Do you have another source besides that and your (admittedly reasonable) speculation?
I agree, Luke, George’s strat on the track sounds wonderful. Paul was a master on the bass, no doubt, but do a search on Youtube of the bass isolated. He seems to struggle on this one, trying to echo what George is playing on the guitar. You can’t hear it on the record but It’s true – listen for yourself.
It’s sad that the North American Rubber Soul album doesn’t even have “Drive My Car” on it. A totally different sounding album with “I’ve Just Seen A Face” as the opening number. No wonder they were not happy with Capitol Records making their own decisions on stuff like this!
Bongo – I think many others in the U.S. will agree with me that “I’ve Just Seen a Face” is a killer opening to Rubber Soul. Really sets off the acoustic feel to the album. I didn’t miss “Drive My Car” at all, though now that I’m accustomed to the Parlaphone CDs I’m glad to have Nowhere Man in the mix.
No offense, but I wonder sometimes if those who grew up with the Capitol version and prefer it have a bit of nostalgic post-hoc rationalization going on. To me, Drive My Car is the greatest album opening ever. The song itself has that classic steamroller Beatles opener quality, and the opening guitar lick screams “Let’s get this started.” It’s clearly how they intended it.
Part of the preference may also be due to perceptions of the album as a whole. Capitol was obviously trying to market to the US folk fan base, and Americans came to view the album as such, but to me one of the magical things about (UK) Rubber Soul is how it seamlessly combines four different genres that were all big at the time: folk, R&B/Motown, LA harmony, and country/western (rockabilly). I feel like the Capitol version sells this album short in that way.
…and wasn’t the R&B flavor of Drive My Car that prompted the ‘Rubber’ Soul title?
It seems very strange to me about how McCartney is credited as playing piano on the actual album sleeve as well as many other sources I’ve encountered, while here on this site, it’s been maintained that it was Lennon who played piano. Granted, since the lead guitar which McCartney claimed to have played is on the same track as the piano part I guess it’s not unreasonable to assume. I personally don’t think the part was beyond Lennon’s abilities on the instrument however limited they obviously were. Even so, I can’t help wondering why if this was indeed the case, Lennon is not known to have objected to McCartney being credited with the piano part. If it was known that he had played it surely he should have been credited on the album sleeve? So then why was McCartney credited instead? And why is there no known record of Lennon having objected to this?
Or maybe was it simply that the lead guitar and piano parts were bounced onto the same track after initially having been recorded on different ones. It is worth keeping in mind that Rubber Soul was the first of the Beatles’ albums on which they made use of the bouncing technique, due to the increasing complexities in their musical arrangements resulting in the four track recording process (which they would continue to rely upon until around the time of The White Album) no longer being able to accommodate them on its own.
But I also have to bring up one more question. In the section of this article concerning the recording process of the song Joe writes…”The group then overdubbed piano, lead guitar, piano and cowbell parts…” Is this supposed to imply that there were two piano overdubs? I just couldn’t bring myself around to that impression listening to the isolated piano part.
A Paul McCartney song that John Lennon also made significant contribution to.Great way to open the wonderful “Rubber Soul” album.Brilliant tongue and cheek lyrics.
This website has some great Lennon lyric sheets:
https://www.the-art-of-john-lennon.net/hand-written-lyric-editions/
I noticed that “Drive My Car” is among them, which is a McCartney tune! Looks like Lennon’s handwriting, although McCartney is the main contributor to the song.
Although Paul wrote the melody it is very plausible that John contributed more to the lyrics, considering that he was a more talented lyricist and that they started it together from scratch.
“Paul’s again. I think that was one of his best songs, too, because the lyrics are good and I didn’t write them. You see? When I say that he could write lyrics if he took the effort, here’s an example. It actually describes the experience taking acid. I think that’s what he’s talking about. I couldn’t swear to it, but I think that it was a result of that.”
John Lennon on Got to get you into my life
Barry,
You cannot go by who wrote Lyrics down on paper. Because in the New Disney “Get Back’ Mal Evans is writing down Lyrics on some of these Songs.
It’s most certainly Paul on bass. George just played the bass line on his guitar so it’s kind of the two of them playing in unison. Even though John was quite capable on piano (examples: Imagine; Ob La Di, Ob La Da; Oh! Darling; I Am The Walrus), I’m pretty sure Paul played the piano on this song. It sounds more like him and he is credited for playing it on the album itself. Keep in mind that this was the period when John started to not participate instrumentally on certain songs written by the others. As for the lead guitar, it’s usually attributed to Paul, but it could very easily be George. I’d have to listen more closely, but are the piano and the lead guitar ever heard at the same time? If so, it most likely couldn’t both be Paul, but if not, then Paul could have easily moved from one instrument to the other. He was, after all, the most skillful musician in the band.
Hey J, I agree with you on the piano being Paul. I could be wrong, but I can’t recall any Beatle or solo John recording where he plays or comes with a piano riff in that feel and style
I guess “you like me too much” is the closest. his ep.
It is clearly John who sings ‘But baby I’ll love you’. Its his sarcasm which reappears on ‘It’s getting better’ and ‘She’s leaving home’.
Isn’t the lead guitar break played with a slide/bottleneck? Kudos for the attempt though I think it took a couple of more years for them to reach maturity using a slide. George’s later slide guitar is really good.
“Drive My Car”… Co-written by a guy who’d only gotten his first driver’s license earlier in the year (at the age of 24!) and couldn’t drive worth a lick.
As a nearly 69 year old who switched over from piano lessons to guitar a few weeks after that famous Ed Sullivan show appearance, and was already playing guitar in (gasp) paid (in real US $) rock and roll bands within 18 months after that, I’d like to inform the apparently younger contributors, based on the chatter about Rock Band, of the following
1) every Beatles new record was a major event, single or Album.
2) we were never disappointed. Magical Mystery Tour was a bit of a weird release, given that some songs were a year old from singles, and others were clearly not their best efforts. But it still had great songs, as did the post-breakup-released mishmash Let it Be. All of the major album releases were amazing, new sounds for their time, often ground-breaking. And virtually all the singles, major events: Paperback writer with Rain on the flip side, or Strawberry Fields, with Penny Land on the flip side. You had to be there!! By the way, I didn’t look up those singles, I just remember them, as none of these songs sounded like anything that anyone had ever recorded before.
3) Very, very few of us cared who sang what part or played what part. We learned all the harmonies as cover bands, sometimes within a day of the record release, at very least to all the singles. And we knew Paul usually sang high harmonies, but due to all the multi-tracked vocals, we could often hardly tell the three of them apart. And who cared? They were all Beatles. And we assumed George played all the leads. Which was usually true, but years later when Paul said he played lead on Taxman and Drive My Car, we were incredulous, but after checking out their similar tone and style, and how they were different from the cleaner concurrent George solos, we were impressed. What a genius!
4) we are very glad that people whose main intro to the Beatles was Rock Band, etc.,, still like the Beatle sounds from 50 or 55 years ago. And sorry you couldn’t have joined us for the actual contemporaneous record-release experience. It was not like the internet,because someone had to rush down to the record store to buy the record and bring it back to play, but maybe more exciting just because of that wait.
For all this talk of John allegedly playing the piano, is there any verifiable evidence to prove it? Another error in the song’s line-up is the tambourine player: it was actually Ringo, not John, and even photographs taken at the session prove that it was Ringo playing it, so Walter Everett made a mistake in his book, but again, he did the best that he could and he is nothing like Ian MacDonald.
As for the guitar parts, George was clearly playing the intro guitar riff as well as elsewhere throughout the song and Paul played slide guitar in addition to the bass guitar, which clearly resembles the tone of his left-handed Rickenbacker bass, so neither George nor John could have feasibly played it and besides, Paul was the one who idolized James Jamerson and Duck Dunn when it came to playing bass, so it’s unrealistic for him to relinquish a soulful bass part to George or John.
It’s an established fact that Paul played all the solo parts in this song, including the intro. You can also tell from the sound and the way he bends the notes.
George just played the high octave bass-line on his guitar.
Paul also played the piano, absolutely no doubt about that, no idea why it still says “John: piano” here, Joe.
As for the vocals: Paul is doing BOTH parts in the verses, he and JOHN are doing the “and maybe I love you” and George is filling in the three part voices.
Thank you, Michael. You are correct that Paul played the piano and even the liner notes to “Rubber Soul” verifies this.
I want to correct some things in your post: the basic track was cut with Paul on bass and George on guitar, so George obviously played the main riff (Walter Everett’s book confirms this), and George himself made it clear that he used a Fender Stratocaster on “Drive My Car” and Paul mimicked George’s playing on his bass, so it gave a good sound.
You are also correct that Paul is playing the slide solo and George also had his own string-bending technique, according to Music Radar, but he wasn’t into slide guitar yet.
Hey Joe, why is the line-up STILL saying that John is playing the piano??
That is definitely Paul playing the bass and the lead guitar.
George would have not been able to play either.
George and John couldn’t play this lead guitar (or bass for that matter) any more than they could play the Taxman solos.
It’s funny to read the musical opinions of non-musicians.
Paul was just on another level than the others when it comes to musicianship.
John rivaled him at song writing (only during the Beatles years, he was washed up afterwards).
Ringo was the only member who played their instrument better than Paul, and Paul was a pretty good drummer, who even played drums on some of the Beatles songs.
It’s funny how threatened and resentful people still are about Paul’s freakish talent, and how they always want to pit him against the other Beatles and make him the villain.
It’s getting better though. The animosity towards Paul has greatly diminished over the decades.
The truth came out that not only did he not break up the Beatles, but we wouldn’t even have the last 2 albums if he had not held the band together against their will and forced John to work, when all he wanted to do at that time was lay around doing heroin with Yoko.
Alert ! The entire Rubber Soul album on YouTube and Google Play is with different vocalists! Like a prank… The proof is in And Maybe I Love you But it’s all over appauling. Ruining there reputation as the best performers, it’s all mellow and slick but above all not their voices ! Disturbing… Who can confirm this please !?!!
Besides the bass line, my favorite parts of this song are the piano chords interspersed here and there. Excellent! But the bass really drives the car in this song, so to speak.
I was wondering for decades regarding the particular harmonics used by Martin for the (insert brand/style of piano) recording of piano sounds in Drive My Car, as well as in For No One, as well as the Rolling Stone’s ‘No Expectations” or Pink Floyd’s “Cymbaline”, for examples.
I could most of those pianos were just stock spinets, but there’s a strange, almost telephone or high pass quality. I asked a sound engineer from WBUR (and former lead guitarist of ‘Big Dipper’) and he claimed, dismissively that it’s just a phase shifter in stationary (non-rotating effect). I don’t think so….anyone able to rock these pages with info about that piano sound/phrasing?