In the studio
Tug Of War was recorded mostly at AIR Studios, owned by George Martin, which had studios in London and Montserrat.
AIR Studios, London: December 1980
The first recording sessions for Tug Of War took place in December 1980 at George Martin’s AIR Studios in London. On 7 December they taped ‘Ballroom Dancing’, ‘Keep Under Cover’, and the unreleased ‘All The Love Is There’. The following day, 8 December, they recorded ‘Rainclouds’ and ‘Ode To A Koala Bear’, both of which became b-sides.
Early in the morning of 9 December came the news that John Lennon had been murdered in New York. Not knowing what else to do, Paul McCartney went to the studio where he worked on overdubs for ‘Rainclouds’ with The Chieftains’ Paddy Moloney. That afternoon he called Yoko Ono to offer his condolences. When he left the studio in the early evening, he was confronted by reporters. His offhand remark – “It’s a drag, innit?” – was considered cold and flippant, but McCartney was merely unable to articulate the breadth of his feelings.
The news of Lennon’s death effectively brought to an end work on Tug Of War for almost a week, but resumed on 14 December with the recording of a demo of ‘Ebony And Ivory’ and further work on ‘Ballroom Dancing’. On 16 December work began on the song ‘Tug Of War’, followed by more recordings two days later, including a birthday song for Linda McCartney’s father Lee Eastman. On 29 December McCartney recorded the 34-second ‘Be What You See (Link)’.
There were also undocumented sessions around this time in Reading, Hastings and Eastbourne in southern England. These would have involved work on ‘Wanderlust’ and an early recording of ‘Take It Away’.
AIR Studios, Montserrat: February-March 1981
Following a Christmas break, McCartney’s musical equipment was flown to Montserrat on 28 January 1981, and the McCartneys arrived on 1 February from New York. The following day they began recording at another branch of George Martin’s AIR Studios.
For the first week McCartney worked with Denny Laine and drummer Dave Mattacks. The first day was mostly taken up with jamming, but on 3 and 4 February they recorded ‘Average Person’, ‘Dress Me Up As A Robber’, ‘The Pound Is Sinking’, and ‘Hear Me Lover’, plus a Laine composition known as ‘Denny’s Song’.
Bassist Stanley Clarke and drummer Steve Gadd arrived on 8 February, the latter replacing Dave Mattacks. In the next few days they worked on songs including ‘Somebody Who Cares’, ‘The Pound Is Sinking’, and early versions of ‘No Values’ from Give My Regards To Broad Street and ‘Hey Hey’ from Pipes Of Peace.
Ringo Starr arrived in Montserrat on 15 February, bringing his wife Barbara Bach and his Ludwig drum kit. He played alongside Gadd for several days, but only one song, ‘Take It Away’, was released.
Another special guest, Carl Perkins, came to Montserrat on 21 February. He and McCartney began recording three days later, performing oldies including ‘Honey Don’t’, ‘Lend Me Your Comb’, and ‘Boppin’ The Blues’. A duet, ‘Get It’, was also taped that day, and Perkins’ tribute to McCartney, ‘My Old Friend’, was recorded on 25 February.
We were in the studio and he came down and said, ‘My, it’s real pretty round here, Paul.’ He went to bed, got up the next morning and he obviously hadn’t seen the island. So he came back later that day and said, ‘Paul, believe me. This morning, I thought I’d died and gone to heaven when I woke up. It’s so pretty here and so beautiful.’ So while he was there, I wrote the track ‘Get It’. We had a bit of fun recording it. I can always see Laurel & Hardy dancing to this track.
The Beatles – The Dream Is Over: Off The Record 2, Keith Badman
Stevie Wonder arrived on 26 February, and the following day began recording with McCartney. They taped a series of jams before working on ‘Ebony And Ivory’ and co-writing ‘What’s That You’re Doing?’. Wonder remained until Monday 2 March, when an all-night session ended at 7am; he left Montserrat later that day, followed by the McCartneys two days later.
As if it was a film, once we had decided that this wasn’t going to be a Wings album, George and I chose the right performers for every track. I wanted to play with Stevie Wonder and we did two together instead. I wanted Steve Gadd on drums and Stanley Clarke on bass simply because they’re the best and I wanted the best. Why not?
AIR Studios, London: March-December 1981
With backing tracks for the songs mostly completed, work continued back at AIR Studios in London on 11 March, when a song known as ‘Newt Rack’ was recorded. The following day an unused reprise of ‘Tug Of War’ was taped, and work continued on ‘The Pound Is Sinking’ and ‘No Values’.
Several unused songs were also recorded around this time, but on 23 March overdubs were added to ‘Take It Away’, ‘Dress Me Up As A Robber’, and ‘Keep Under Cover’. The sessions came to an end on 30 March with recording and mixing for ‘Get It’, ‘No Values’, ‘Ebony And Ivory’, ‘Tug Of War Reprise’, ‘What’s That You’re Doing?’, ‘Wanderlust’, ‘Keep Under Cover’, ‘The Pound Is Sinking’, ‘All The Love There Is’, and ‘Sweetest Little Show’.
Absent from these sessions was Denny Laine, but around this time McCartney began collaborating with Eric Stewart, formerly of The Mindbenders and 10cc. McCartney and Stewart worked together extensively on Tug Of War, Pipes Of Peace and Press To Play, and Stewart’s technique of building a choir of backing vocals through extensive overdubbing was frequently utilised.
In May 1981 Michael Jackson and McCartney collaborated on two songs, ‘Say Say Say’ and ‘The Man’; work continued over the next two years. During June and July overdubbing and mixing resumed on all of the Tug Of War songs recorded to date, plus a new piece entitled ‘Simon’s Wigwam’.
Following a two-week break in August, McCartney worked on a range of non-album recordings, as well as further mixing for the album. This work continued until October; at this stage ‘Keep Under Cover’, ‘Tug Of War Reprise’, and ‘No Values’ were all under consideration for inclusion.
In the summer of 1981 McCartney worked on several tracks in the loft of The Mill at his Sussex home; the building was later renovated and became Hog Hill Mill studio. The songs included ‘Here Today’, his tribute to John Lennon which had been written earlier that year. It featured McCartney on vocals and acoustic guitar, plus a string quartet arranged by George Martin.
Work on Tug Of War came to a close in March 1981, by which time more than 20 songs had been completed. From this 12 songs were selected for inclusion on the album.
Cover artwork
The cover for Tug Of War was designed by Hipgnosis and Sinc. It featured photography by Linda McCartney and artwork by Brian Clarke, who subsequently became a long-term collaborator with the McCartneys.
The release
Tug Of War had originally been scheduled for release in October 1981, but by that time the recordings were still incomplete. It was pushed back to 15 February 1982, but further work again made this impossible.
Further dates of 12 March and 2 April were announced and cancelled, with the reason for the final delay given as “problems with the artwork”. ‘Ebony And Ivory’ was issued as a single in March 1982, with ‘Rainclouds’ on the b-side. It topped the charts in a number of countries.
Tug Of War was eventually released on 26 April 1982. The delays helped increase anticipation for the album, along with the reunion of McCartney and George Martin, the success of ‘Ebony And Ivory’, and speculation of how McCartney would respond in song to the death of John Lennon.
Fortunately, it didn’t disappoint, and the album became McCartney’s last to top the US charts until 2018’s Egypt Station. In Japan it was the first number one and the biggest selling album by a European performer since 1977.
In the UK it entered the album charts at number one, where it remained for two weeks. It spent a total of 27 weeks in the charts.
A second single, ‘Take It Away’, followed in June 1982. Its b-side was ‘I’ll Give You A Ring’. The video featured Ringo Starr and George Martin, as well as actor John Hurt.
Tug Of War is a great album and one of McCartneys best solo efforts in conjunction with his old mentor George Martin. Take It Away, the big hit is a brilliant song and a real favorite of mine. As also are the great title track Tug Of War, Ballroom Dancing and the beautiful Wanderlust. But it is his oh so moving tribute to his old partner John Lennon – Here Today – that really takes the cake.
Any info about the technical aspects of this recording? It was “mixed digitally” – were the actual tracks recorded to tape and then digitized in the mix?
Say What?!? Take It Away was the album’s big hit??? I could’ve sworn that the song only climbed to number 10 on the U.S. charts. That’s certainly not shabby at all but c’mon, what happened to Ebony And Ivory? I kind of think staying at number 1 for seven weeks AND being ranked as the 59th greatest song of the rock era (Billboard) kind of makes Ebony And Ivory a slightly bigger hit than Take It Away.
I think it’s a question of taste otherwise. My personal favorite on the album was always Wanderlust. I really don’t think McCartney’s voice was ever finer or clearer. Here Today gets a lot of attention due to the subject matter, but had the song been written 5 years earlier it would likely have been easily – and rightly – overlooked as filler. It’s stylistically not a lot different from You Gave Me The Answer and certainly doesn’t deserve to ascend the Olympian heights of songs like Yesterday (or even George’s All Those Years Ago) just because of the weeping violins thrown in for mood.
All that said, I always thought this album was McCartney’s true masterpiece. Conventional opinion says the honor belongs to Band on the Run, but I think that track for track, Tug of War is a more fully realized album with songs that – had they been written by lesser songwriters – would’ve represented career achievements. (Band on the Run would be right behind it.
I don’t think TOW is one of Paul’s very best post-Beatles albums – there are too many tracks on it that I skip, and I would never say that about… say, Ram, Band on the Run, Red Rose Speedway – heck, even Flaming Pie. But the songs on it that I do like I like a great deal: “Wanderlust,” “Take It Away,” and “Here Today” deserve the acclaim they’ve already received here, and the title track is suitably grand to merit, well, being the title track. I’d also like to throw in a good word for “The Pound is Sinking.” It is redolent of “Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey” to it with its shifts in tone and tempo, and his vocal, particularly in the little section toward the end (i.e., “I knew you for a minute, oh it didn’t happen”) is magnificent. On the repackaged remaster release that came out in 2015, there are a couple of tracks that I absolutely adore: “Rainclouds” and “I’ll Give You a Ring” are just perfect Paul, and were apparently B-sides that I like better than their A-sides.
“Ebony and Ivory” is one that I don’t listen to often, I admit. I was a young kid when it was like radio wallpaper, and it hasn’t perhaps aged as well as it might have, but melodically and vocally it’s a beautifully crafted and delivered little song.
Probably the all-time best McCartney album. There’s maybe two or three tracks that aren’t among the best in his catalogue, and even those are better than most musicians can do on a good day. Wanderlust is the absolute standout track and probably the pinnacle of his career in my opinion.
Still a wonderful album, but I don’t like the 2016 remixed version at all.
Tug of War is the only LP by Wings or McCartney that I was impressed with on the whole. Paul is somewhat of a slouch and George Harrisons remark “Everybody needs someone to tell him what is good” says it all. Without George Martin Tug of war would have been just another uncompleted and to a degree disappointing LP by Paul.
McCartney´s problem is that he does not understand if a song is good and if it is finished. On the other hand, deep inside he knows. He understood that Maybe I´m amazed was good and his favourite on Flaming pie was Souvenir, the best song on that CD. It is his laissez-faire side that so often ruins it. He is a rather lazy composer and lyricist.
People who get certified geniuses when they’re young tend to lose the ability to edit themselves and practice quality control. I think it’s fair to say that of McCartney, of Dylan, and of Prince, all three. Of course, they’re all great and need prove nothing, but in all three cases, their work started getting inconsistent around the time they turned 30. Then, any above-average album would get a “He’s back! He’s turned the corner!” type of critical/fan response.
I do not think any of the Beatles ever escaped the shadow of the Beatles — George’s and John’s solo outputs were no less spotty — but Paul gets more guff for his because it’s gone on the longest and he hasn’t taken any long breaks. Also, some of his uninspired work was commercially successful, so more people know about it. If you go through almost 50 years of Wings/Paul material and choose the cream of the crop, you could make a four-disc box set that would make it look like one triumph after another. But those great tracks get swamped in filler and half-realized ideas. I agree that Tug of War is one of his strongest sets.
I agree with you.
everything after wings over america and before flowers in the dirt is just horrible. except for “no more lonely nights”, his best 80s song. “dress me up as a robber” from this album is pretty good too, but as a whole it’s a bad album. “pipes of peace” is even worse, there’s not a single good song on that one. tug of war, pipes of peace, give my regards and press to play are so horrible that you can’t make an album out of all of them combined.
I recommend the stuff from RAM up to wings over america, then skip to flowers in the dirt. since flowers up to driving rain he was great. then he started sucking again since chaos.
he’s very unstable, he can be the best genius in pop and rock music in one album and then spend 10 years making awful uninspired albums where nothing happens.
at least his live albums are great.
I strongly disagree, while sharing dislike for “Give my regards” and the praise for “No more lonely nights”.
But “Once upon a long ago” is just as good as that one, and “Tug of war” has so many great tracks on it that it’s rightfully considered one of his most consistently good albums.
“London Town” is surprisingly good, too, btw. Not many hits at all, but I hardly ever skip any track on it.
TOW is a different animal though. First class musicians, first class production, first class sound, first class songs (I don’t like Ballroom dancing, but it still has this fantastic clarinet).
If you don’t like it – fine, but obviously it’s very far from being “just horrible” and very far superiour to albums like “Red Rose Speedway”, “Wings wild life” oder “Wings at the speed of sound”.
Yes, much better than “Red Rose Speedway”, “Wings wild life” oder “Wings at the speed of sound”.
Sorry, I forgot to mention his later work, which you completely dismiss, too.
So you say “Electric arguments” is an album “where nothing happens”. ‘kay.
Making a (highly acclaimed) jazz-album for the first time means “nothing happens”, too, to you. Uhu.
“New” and “Memory almost full” weren’t as great or consistent as “Tug of war”, but still very good and at LEAST as good as “Driving rain”, for sure.
Dude, if that’s your taste, so be it. But calling “Electric Arguments” an album “where nothing happens” when it may be his most versatile album since Ram you don’t give yourself much credibility.
Just saying.
Definitely one of Paul’s best albums. This really is the album we knew he could make and it didn’t disappoint. There’s a lot of variety with the songs he wrote and recorded. I’m glad George Martin produced it because he made this album great. McCartney himself is a good producer too.
Martin not only produced it, but also told McCartney to work on his songs for the album until they were fully developed. That is the biggest difference compared to all McCartney´s other albums. He had to work and work on the songs until Martin okayed them. That sort of input is what McCartney has always needed and still needs the most.
Tug of war is a good album, but in spite of that not as good as beatle-Paul material. This is one difference between Paul and John: John sometimes published self-penned songs who´s basic material holds Beatles quality, but McCartney has very rarely done that. He is more of a quantity before quality artist.
John Lennon songs from his solo career, that in my opinion holds about the same song material quality as his songs for The Beatles:
Imagine
Jealous guy
Gimme some truth
(Just like) Starting over
Watching the wheels
Woman
Free as a bird
Real love
Grow old with me
Mother
Working class hero
Isolation
Woman is the n—-r of the world
Paul McCartney songs from his solo career, that in my opinion holds about the same song material quality as his songs for The Beatles:
Maybe I´m amazed
Uncle Albert
No words (Chords, melodies and words basically by Denny Laine)
Ditto songs written by McCartney after Lennon´s death:
Souvenir
From a lover to a friend
Friends to go
I like McCartney´s and Lennon´s Beatles songs equally.
I strongly disagree. Looking at your list of Lennon’s supposedly Beatles worthy solo songs I would actually rate these as quantity over quality. Many of them are of the confessional soft/dad rock type for my liking. Many of McCartney’s solo songs are absurdly overlooked. I guess it’s all down to opinion though. In the seventies, both John and Paul wrote in equal measure tracks worthy of any Beatles album – just as they did when they were together in the Beatles.
Your point of view is really interesting. It is obvious that subjectivity is important when it comes to what music one likes. On the other hand it is an objective fact that practically everyone likes the material of The Beatles much more than that of Lennon and McCartney from rheir solo careers. This says a lot.
Which songs from McCartney´s solo career do you find overlooked?
I find George’s comments on Paul’s solo efforts to be rather hypocritical, arrogant even. After all much of George’s solo output after All Things Must Pass wasn’t exactly stellar; perhaps he was the one who needed to learn the difference between a good song and a bad song.
I definitely agree with you regarding that George Harrison needed someone to tell him what material he should and should not release.
George was not a very good songwriter. In my opinion he is very overrated as such. Other artists, among them McCartney, have said that he was such a good songwriter, but I wonder if they believe it themselves. Even All things must pass is not very good. My Sweet Lord is wonderful, but he stole that one. The rest of the songs are never better than the rating 5/10.
The thing is, George would not have been able to write better songs even if he had gotten honest feed back. The somewhat tragic fact about Paul, though, is that he could have done that.
I was amused to find out Wanderlust is basically a drug song (named for the boat Wings rented in the Caribbean during London Town sessions, to hang out and smoke dope on) ?