Log In
Register
4.47pm
4 August 2015
Offline
I didn’t question #2 because like somebody said, Across The Universe had two versions, the one on Let It Be and the one on the wildlife compilation album.
My vision was for stuff like you might have seen on the Rarities album. But I won’t split hairs. Let us proceed with #10. If needed, I will add one tomorrow.
The following people thank Jolly Jimmy for this post:
kelicopterYou are all my friends.
9.13pm
Moderators
Members
Reviewers
20 August 2013
Offline 13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
Describe at least one difference
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of six. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. While My Guitar Gently Weeps (White Album version is a soaring rock song with Clapton on lead guitar; the Anthology version is a contemplative acoustic version performed by George, with an extra verse.)
9. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
10. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
Can buy Joe love! Amazon | iTunes
Check here for "how do I do this" guide to the forum. 
(2017) 
(2018)
1.02am
24 March 2014
Offline
13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
Describe at least one difference
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of six. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. While My Guitar Gently Weeps (White Album version is a soaring rock song with Clapton on lead guitar; the Anthology version is a contemplative acoustic version performed by George, with an extra verse.)
9. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
10. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
11. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
"I Need You by George Harrison"
6.50am
4 August 2015
Offline 
13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
Describe at least one difference
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
2a. Across The Universe (We also have the wildlife version with bird sound effects and two girls providing background vocals.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
3a. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of 6. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. While My Guitar Gently Weeps (White Album version is a soaring rock song with Clapton on lead guitar; the Anthology version is a contemplative acoustic version performed by George, with an extra verse.)
9. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
9a. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
10. I’m Looking Through You (American LP version includes a false start)
Note: I renumbered songs shown twice as supplements to original submission. I like seeing the additional information. But we are looking for 13 distinct songs.
You are all my friends.
7.04am
Reviewers
17 December 2012
Offline @Jolly Jimmy, sorry to throw up another one (and thanks for tidying the list), but I question Penny Lane at 5 since the version cited was only sent out as a mono promo single to radio stations in the US and Canada and was replaced with the officially released version by the time of the single. It did not appear on an official Beatles release until the Pepper 50th anniversary edition (the version on the US Rarities was a fake, adding the extra piccolo trumpet notes to the stereo mix).
"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
To @ Ron Nasty it's @ mja6758
The Beatles Bible 2020 non-Canon Poll Part One: 1958-1963 and Part Two: 1964-August 1966
9.05am
4 August 2015
Offline @Ron Nasty , I thought of that too. But I wasn’t sure what to do about it. I was more concerned with once bootlegged demos and alternate takes later released on the Anthology CDs.
Maybe after we complete this list and start a new one, I’ll throw in a couple more for the halibut.
You are all my friends.
9.27am
Reviewers
17 December 2012
Offline You’re always free to remove items that don’t fit the criteria you were aiming for, @Jolly Jimmy. It happens regularly in this thread.
"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
To @ Ron Nasty it's @ mja6758
The Beatles Bible 2020 non-Canon Poll Part One: 1958-1963 and Part Two: 1964-August 1966
11.29am
28 April 2020
Offline 13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
Describe at least one difference
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
2a. Across The Universe (We also have the wildlife version with bird sound effects and two girls providing background vocals.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
3a. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of 6. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
8a. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
9. I’m Looking Through You (American LP version includes a false start)
Note: I renumbered songs shown twice as supplements to original submission. I like seeing the additional information. But we are looking for 13 distinct songs.
I’ve removed ‘While My Guitar Gently Weeps ‘
1.36pm
11 September 2018
Offline 13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
Describe at least one difference
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
2a. Across The Universe (We also have the wildlife version with bird sound effects and two girls providing background vocals.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
3a. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of 6. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
8a. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
9. I’m Looking Through You (American LP version includes a false start)
10. Yellow Submarine (John can be heard repeating the first line of the third verse in the mono version, whereas in the stereo version he doesn’t come in until the second line.)
4.44pm
11 June 2015
Offline 13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
Describe at least one difference
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
2a. Across The Universe (We also have the wildlife version with bird sound effects and two girls providing background vocals.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
3a. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).*
5R. From Me To You (The mono mix has a harmonica added during the intro)
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of 6. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
8a. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
9. I’m Looking Through You (American LP version includes a false start)
10. Yellow Submarine (John can be heard repeating the first line of the third verse in the mono version, whereas in the stereo version he doesn’t come in until the second line.)
*I am so accustomed to listening to the version with the extra piccolo, I forget it’s source. Let’s try a different song.
You and I have memories
Longer than the road that stretches out ahead
4.53pm
Reviewers
Moderators
1 May 2011
Offline 13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
Describe at least one difference
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
2a. Across The Universe (We also have the wildlife version with bird sound effects and two girls providing background vocals.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
3a. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).*
5R. From Me To You (The mono mix has a harmonica added during the intro)
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of 6. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
8a. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
9. I’m Looking Through You (American LP version includes a false start)
10. Yellow Submarine (John can be heard repeating the first line of the third verse in the mono version, whereas in the stereo version he doesn’t come in until the second line.)
11. Get Back – The album version has dialogue that the single does not whereas the single has a coda that the album does not.
"I told you everything I could about me, Told you everything I could" ('Before Believing' - Emmylou Harris)
7.48pm
4 August 2015
Offline 13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
2a. Across The Universe (We also have the wildlife version with bird sound effects and two girls providing background vocals.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
3a. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).*
5R. From Me To You (The mono mix has a harmonica added during the intro)
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of 6. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
8a. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
9. I’m Looking Through You (American LP version includes a false start)
10. Yellow Submarine (John can be heard repeating the first line of the third verse in the mono version, whereas in the stereo version he doesn’t come in until the second line.)
11. Get Back – The album version has dialogue that the single does not whereas the single has a coda that the album does not.
12. I Should Have Known Better (At beginning of stereo version, harmonica riff gets cut short a note shortly before vocals. It’s ok on the mono version)
You are all my friends.
3.13am
Reviewers
17 December 2012
Offline 13 BEATLE SONGS WITH MORE THAN ONE OFFICIALLY RELEASED VERSION
1. Thank You Girl (One version has extra harmonica in middle and at end. The other has no harmonica in those spots.)
2. Across The Universe (Original album version was overproduced by Phil Spector, while the Naked version is raw and kind of perfect.)
2a. Across The Universe (We also have the wildlife version with bird sound effects and two girls providing background vocals.)
3. Helter Skelter (No fadeouts and fade ins on mono mix)
3a. Helter Skelter – Ringo’s “I got blisters on my fingers!” only in stereo mix.
4. Let It Be (LP version has louder guitar solo than the single 45 version)
5. Penny Lane (original single had an additional flourish of piccolo trumpet notes at the end of the song).*
5R. From Me To You (The mono mix has a harmonica added during the intro)
6. Love Me Do (Ringo was relegated to playing tambourine while session drummer Andy White played drums. This version is on the ‘Please Please Me ‘ album. A version with Ringo on drums appears on ‘Past Masters ‘)
7. I Am The Walrus (On American 45 version, opening riff is heard 4 times instead of 6. There is also an extra second or two of music between “I’m crying” and Yellow matter custard”).
8. Help ! – The mono mix has an entirely different John lead vocal to the stereo, the tambourine is also missing.
8a. Help ! (a different difference – if this doesn’t count, I can delete it) – The US Capitol version has the James Bond bit at the beginning.
9. I’m Looking Through You (American LP version includes a false start)
10. Yellow Submarine (John can be heard repeating the first line of the third verse in the mono version, whereas in the stereo version he doesn’t come in until the second line.)
11. Get Back – The album version has dialogue that the single does not whereas the single has a coda that the album does not.
12. I Should Have Known Better (At beginning of stereo version, harmonica riff gets cut short a note shortly before vocals. It’s ok on the mono version)
13. Don’t Pass Me By (the mono mix is much faster than the stereo and has more fiddle playing from Jack Fallon at the end)
13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
To @ Ron Nasty it's @ mja6758
The Beatles Bible 2020 non-Canon Poll Part One: 1958-1963 and Part Two: 1964-August 1966
3.40am
11 April 2016
Offline 13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
2. Paul McCartney : Here Today
"WeepyC came into the fray as the premier Jimmy Page fan, and will remain." - sir walter raleigh
2016 & 2017: 
2020: 
4.19am
11 September 2018
Offline 13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
2. Paul McCartney : Here Today
3. Liverpool John Lennon Airport
5.00am
24 March 2014
Offline 13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
2. Paul McCartney : Here Today
3. Liverpool John Lennon Airport
"I Need You by George Harrison"
6.49am
4 August 2015
Offline 13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
2. Paul McCartney : Here Today
3. Liverpool John Lennon Airport
5. The album Working Class Hero : A Tribute To John Lennon
You are all my friends.
7.03am
Reviewers
17 December 2012
Offline 13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
2. Paul McCartney : Here Today
3. Liverpool John Lennon Airport
4. Statue in Almería
5. The album Working Class Hero : A Tribute To John Lennon
6. Strawberry Fields, Central Park, New York City
"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
To @ Ron Nasty it's @ mja6758
The Beatles Bible 2020 non-Canon Poll Part One: 1958-1963 and Part Two: 1964-August 1966
7.25am
24 March 2014
Offline 13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
2. Paul McCartney : Here Today
3. Liverpool John Lennon Airport
5. The album Working Class Hero : A Tribute To John Lennon
6. Strawberry Fields, Central Park, New York City
7. Lennon Gallagher. Liam’s son
The following people thank Shamrock Womlbs for this post:
kelicopter"I Need You by George Harrison"
7.48am
4 August 2015
Offline 13 John Lennon tributes
(they don’t need to be songs, can also include tributes such as statues, places named after him, etc.)
1. George Harrison (with contributions Paul and Ringo): All Those Years Ago
2. Paul McCartney : Here Today
3. Liverpool John Lennon Airport
5. The album Working Class Hero : A Tribute To John Lennon
6. Strawberry Fields, Central Park, New York City
7. Lennon Gallagher. Liam’s son
8. The TV special Come Together : A Night for John Lennon ‘s Words and Music in 2001
You are all my friends.
2 Guest(s)