In the studio
Having finished touring in August 1966, The Beatles were free to spend time in the studio working on their next masterpiece. As EMI owned the studio at Abbey Road time and costs were of little consequence, and The Beatles knew that the songs recorded wouldn’t have to be performed live.The first songs to be recorded for Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band were ‘When I’m Sixty-Four’, ‘Strawberry Fields Forever’, and ‘Penny Lane’. ‘When I’m Sixty-Four’ actually had its origins in The Beatles’ Hamburg days, although it was recorded in December 1966.
‘Penny Lane’ and ‘Strawberry Fields Forever’, meanwhile, were taken for the group’s first single of 1967, a decision which George Martin later described as “a dreadful mistake”.
The album’s monumental closer, ‘A Day In The Life’, was recorded from 19 January 1967, becoming the second Sgt Pepper song to be taped. The third was the title track, which was first recorded on 1 February.
I used to share a flat in Sloane Street with Mal [Evans]. One day in February Paul called, saying that he was writing a song and asking if he and Mal could come over. The song was the start of Sgt Pepper.At my place he carried on writing and the song developed. At the end of every Beatles show, Paul used to say, ‘It’s time to go. We’re going to go to bed, and this is our last number.’ Then they’d play the last number and leave. Just then Mal went to the bathroom, and I said to Paul, ‘Why don’t you have Sgt Pepper as the compere of the album? He comes on at the beginning of the show and introduces the band, and at the end he closes it. A bit later, Paul told John about it in the studio, and John came up to me and said, ‘Nobody likes a smart-arse, Neil.’
Soon after The Beatles began recording the song ‘Sgt Pepper’, they realised that it could introduce a fictitious concert.
The idea came about gradually. Basically it was Paul’s idea: he came in and said he had the song ‘Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band’ and that he was identifying it with the band, with The Beatles themselves. We recorded the song first, and then the thought came to make it into an idea for the album. It was at a time when they wanted to concentrate on the studio, and that probably fomented the idea of the alter-ego group: ‘Let Sgt Pepper do the touring.’
Anthology
The album was recorded on four-track machines; at the time, eight-tracks were only available in US commercial studios. This undoubtedly caused The Beatles to think creatively about how to best use the recording technology at their disposal.
As with previous album, reduction mixes were used to free up spare tracks and allow the group to continue recording. The reprise version of the title song was the only one of the album not to be mixed in this way.
‘A Day In The Life’ arguably saw The Beatles at the peak of their creative powers. The song perfectly combined fragments by both John Lennon and Paul McCartney, and the impact of the two orchestral crescendos and the final crashing piano chord have scarcely lessened with the passing years.
George Martin and Paul McCartney conducted the orchestral glissando, with Martin supplying some basic instructions to the musicians, many of whom were from the Royal Philharmonic and London Symphony orchestras.
At the very beginning I put into the musical score the lowest note each instrument could play, ending with an E major chord. And at the beginning of each of the 24 bars I put a note showing roughly where they should be at that point. Then I had to instruct them. ‘We’re going to start very very quietly and end up very very loud. We’re to start very low in pitch and end up very high. You’ve got to make your own way up there, as slidey as possible so that the clarinets slurp, trombones gliss, violins slide without fingering any notes. And whatever you do, don’t listen to the fellow next to you because I don’t want you to be doing the same thing.’ Of course they all looked at me as though I was mad…
The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, Mark Lewisohn
The final Sgt Pepper recording session took place on 21 April 1967. Creative to the last, The Beatles decided that there should be no silence at the end of the album. Instead, they recorded a burst of nonsensical gibberish which was pressed in the album’s run-out groove – following a brief high-pitched 15 kHz tone intended for dogs.
They were all there discussing how to end the LP but the decision to throw in a bit of nonsense gibberish came together in about 10 minutes. They ran down to the studio floor and we recorded them twice – on each track of a two-track tape. They made funny noises, said random things; just nonsense. We chopped up the tape, put it back together, played it backwards and threw it in.It took Harry [Moss, disc cutter] about eight attempts to get it right because the slightest incorrect placing of a stylus at the very beginning of the LP side can put the concentric groove out. We had to enquire if putting musical content in the run-out groove would tear the metal when the records are stamped out at the factory.
An early version of the tracklisting had the songs on side one in a slightly different order, possibly in an attempt to prolong the idea of the stage show. In early April 1967 the album had the songs in this order: ‘Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band’; ‘With A Little Help From My Friends’; ‘Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite!’; ‘Fixing A Hole’; ‘Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds’; ‘Getting Better’; ‘She’s Leaving Home’.
Ah yes Avery Road my fav Beatles album.lol
I read a quote from George once where he stated for him making Sgt Peppers was not a pleasant experience. It was Paul’s baby and he only allowed the others to contribute as he saw fit.
Personally I prefer the White Album and Revolver and Abbey Road being my fav Beatles album.
I’m sure you have Martin on camera or tape saying this correct? All I’ve ever seen Sir George speak about was how he took two “incomplete” songs given to him from Paul and John where he worked out the basic arrangement which eventually became Day In The Life.
Trixie is referring to George Harrison who indeed stated he was not really “into” that album when recording it.
George Martin didn’t weld the two parts of “….Life”. John and Paul did. Then Paul and George M. worked out the arrangements.
Beatles Bible states that “Sgt. Pepper” was issued (in the UK) on 1st June 1967. I am certain it was issued on 26th May 1967. The Beatle Monthly magazine issued on 1st June 1967 indicates that the release had already happened and the album entered the UK album chart at No. 1 on a chart published 1st June 1967, both signifying that the release must be before 1st June. Interestingly, the 2017 50th anniversary remix/reissue was released on 26th May 2017, which ties in exactly with what I think/remember as being the original release date in 1967.
Game changer. I think John outshone Paul on this one. The most creative song (in my opinion) was George’s song, though. That song changed me.
I would like to know if you intend to take into account the information that appears in the 50th anniversary deluxe edition of “Sgt Pepper”. There are lots of new and interesting things. For example, John’s bass in “Fixing a Hole,” George’s mellotron on “Strawberry …” or Paul and Ringo drumming on “Good Morning …”, which explains that full sound. However, there are also contradictions or omissions. For example, in “Strawberry …” they do not say who plays the piano or percussion. In “A Day in the Life” it says that John plays piano, but it does not specify if it only refers to the final chord, because in the line-up it does not specify who they played in that chord. In “Being the benefit …” they omit John’s piano and Lowery, but they talk about a Martin mellotron. What do you think?
Paul overdubbed bass on “Fixing a Hole” and AFAIK, John and George both played guitars on “Good Morning, Good Morning” with Paul playing the guitar solo as well as bass and the double drums with Ringo, just as you mentioned.
A number of sources (Wikipedia being one, so tread lightly) say that the album was going to be called Dr. Pepper’s LHCB, but wasn’t because of the soda in the US. If true, that puts Macca’s name origin story in a different light.
On Sgt Pepper, (on the CD) shouldn’t the “hidden track” be somehow hidden instead of tagged on the end of A Day In The Life? Like with a signal that the CD is over and just ends, unless you hit the skip button to go to the final track before it stops (if you want to hear it). I mean it would be a little more “in the day” that way.
Beatles fandom myth begins…”Sgt. Peppers is the first concept album”. Myth dispelled by actual Beatle John, who says, ” besides the opening song leading into the next song, you could take any song off this album and put it onto any of our albums”. Of course, as we all know, a concept album is when all songs were written with a predetermined theme each relating to another. When I’m 64 was written by Paul when he was 16. Benefit for Mr.Kite was written by John by essentially rewriting what he had read off an antique poster.
Who keeps adding musician names to the list and why?!?
Joe, the site creator/moderator does as he becomes aware of more information.
Pretty simple, isn’t it?!?
In Part 4 above, George Harrison is quoted as saying, “I’d just got back from India, and my heart was still out there. After what had happened in 1966, everything else seemed like hard work. It was a job, like doing something I didn’t really want to do, and I was losing interest in being ‘fab’ at that point.”
What was it that had happened in 1966??
Brian Epstein died, then they went on their transformational trip to India. I think that was the order of things, though I could be wrong. They were all grieving Epstein’s death, and people handle grief in different ways. Paul poured himself into work, and I guess George didn’t feel like it. He did come up with probably the most meaningful song on the album, though, Within You, Without You, obviously inspired by his time in India, and, to an extent, his grief.
As for the Personnel section: Paul: vocals, … and drums (Good Morning Good Morning). First time for Paul on drums on the Beatles album. By the way, does anyone know if Paul played one of Ringo’s drum kits here?
From “Mad Magazine” when I was probably 11. I was nine when SPLHCB was released.
“Ringo, George, Paul and John, played a trick and put us on. Dropped a hint that Paul was dead as nails and rocketed their record sales”
I first heard Sergeant Pepper in about 1974 I think, I borrowed it from a friend at school when I would have been about 16. I was a Beatles fan by default almost, to people of my generation they were just there, and you expected them to come out with brilliant things. I was extremely disappointed by this album which I thought sounded muddy compared to other Beatles efforts. I had heard Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields by then, but the only songs from the album as such that I recognised were When I’m 64 and With a Little Help From My Friends, possibly only from covers, so the material was farily new to my ears. I still think that notwithstanding its brilliance it is questionable whether as a sum of its parts it equals other Beatles albums, before or after. There are only a couple of songs in my view on the album or released as singles that are good songs and are also as well arranged and produced as they could be, including Fixing a Hole and Within You Without You. There are other brilliant songs such as With a Little Help From My Friends, When I’m 64, Lucy in the Sky, Good Morning that are really to my ears let down by the arrangements. I would also include Penny Lane (is that clunky piano really that interesting?) and A Day in the Life (this is a pop group/rock band whatever, who let that orchestra in here, they’re ruining the song?!). And then there are items of what could just be whimsy such as Lovely Rita which is almost perfectly arranged and produced, and Getting Better, which in the absence of its arrangement performance and production would barely be a song at all, but which I think is one of the most brilliantly executed recordings they ever produced. So coming to it some years after it was issued it struck me as patchy, and still does.
I don’t blame EMI for rejecting John’s brash suggestion of putting Hitler on the cover, because it would have been very offensive to Germans and survivors of the Nazi regime. According to Horst Fascher, John would often greet the audiences at the clubs in Hamburg with a Heil Hitler and give the Nazi salute, pull out a black comb and pretend it was a moustache, so that he could look like Hitler.
I’m surprised that John didn’t get arrested by the German authorities or put in a Hamburg prison, because giving the Nazi salute or chanting “Sieg Heil” is a criminal offence in Germany, according to Strafgesetzbuch section 86a.
As for the Personnel section: Paul: vocals, … and drums (Good Morning Good Morning). First time for Paul on drums on the Beatles album. By the way, does anyone know if Paul played one of Ringo’s drum kits here?
I have seen a photo where Ringo is playing his drum kit at a studio session and a clean-shaven Paul is standing up with some drumsticks, presumably to play on the floor tom.
The second drum part in question on “GM, GM” could well have been Ringo and Paul collaborating on double drumming and to clarify things, Paul’s part would, logically, have been intended to augment, not replace, Ringo’s drumming – an earlier instance occurred on the recording of “Yes it is” when Paul overdubbed a cymbal, again to augment Ringo’s drums.
Sorry, but for anyone who puts SPLHCB down in any way (notwithstanding comparing that which preceeded or followed) basically you need to go get some new ears. Any of the more recent masterings show that the main driver (Sir Paul) steered the Beatle ship at this period. The guy was basically on fire from 66 onwards when the touring ceased
I always wanted to know WHY Paul turned his back to the camera for the back cover photo? And why would they use that photo for the album? It is so odd a choice. It practically invites the “Paul is dead” crowd to notice and interpret.
I suppose we’ll never know.
I remember hearing that it was Mal Evans standing in for Paul on that back cover shot – forget why, but McCartney wasn’t at the shoot (separate one from the cover)
I never heard the Mal stand in story. Makes sense if it’s true. Thanks for sharing.
Cheers!
Mal Evans standing in for Paul? In his biography on this website Joe describes Mal as “tall and burley.” Paul was hardly tall and burly. Couldn’t be Mal unless someone manipulated the photo to make Mal look more like Paul in stature.
That’s true. Mal Evans was 6 feet 3 inches tall.
Paul is 5 feet 10 inches. Unless it’s a cardboard cutout of Paul’s back as a subtle allusion to the front cover? Someone should ask Paul!
https://www.theguardian.com/music/2023/aug/14/photo-that-solves-sgt-pepper-mccartney-mystery-up-for-auction
“It had long been rumoured that Paul McCartney was not at the Sgt Pepper’s sleeve photo shoot because the back of the album only showed him from behind. This image showed the side of his face which would prove that he was indeed there on the day.”
So this photo shone on The Guardian website from Aug 14 2023 proves McCartney was present at the Pepper photo-shoot for the back cover. But the question remains… Why turn your back, Paul?